Economic Self-Reliance Must Go Beyond the Factory
Economic Self-Reliance Must Go Beyond the Factory
Note: This article is the author’s personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the CNBCIndonesia.com editorial team.
Indonesia’s trade surplus is sending a signal we should not ignore. From January to July 2026, the surplus was only US$3.70 billion, down around 84 per cent compared with the same period a year earlier. Imports rose by nearly 20 per cent, while exports grew by just 4.4 per cent. Even the 2025 surplus of US$41.05 billion was underpinned by an oil and gas deficit of US$19.70 billion.
These figures could be read as ordinary trade fluctuations. But they raise a more fundamental question: how self-reliant is our industry really? Perhaps we have succeeded in building many factories, but have not done enough to establish the foundations that would allow them to operate independently when overseas supplies are disrupted.
That question prompted me to develop the Indonesian Strategic Self-Reliance Index (IKSI). This is not an official statistic, but an analytical tool I use to assess 20 strategic sectors across five dimensions: production base, import dependence, technological mastery, value chains and global competitiveness. The simple question is: if ships stopped sailing tomorrow, what would we still be able to produce ourselves?
The average IKSI score is 64.1. Coal scored 91, palm oil 88, while natural gas and payment systems each scored 84. At first glance, these figures are reassuring. The problem is that this strength does not always rest on an equally strong foundation.
Mines, crude palm oil (CPO) plants, smelters and the automotive industry all need machinery, electronics and components, some of which still come from abroad. Industrial machinery scored only 39, while electronics and semiconductors scored 25, the lowest among the 20 sectors analysed. Semiconductor imports rose from US$2.33 billion in 2020 to US$4.87 billion in January-November 2025.
This is where the paradox lies. Six relatively strong sectors—coal, palm oil, natural gas, nickel, payment systems and automotive—had an average score of 80.5. But the critical inputs that underpin them averaged just 34.3. There is a 46-point gap between the structure that looks solid and the foundation supporting it.
Trade data for 2026 reinforce this picture. From January to April, imports of raw materials rose by 11.67 per cent to US$61.82 billion, while imports of capital goods surged by 19.02 per cent to US$17.11 billion.
Industry is moving forward, but some of that movement is still powered by materials and machinery from overseas. Rising imports in the context of industrial expansion are not necessarily bad, but deep dependence leaves domestic production vulnerable when global supply chains are disrupted.
This is not to say that our achievements are insignificant. Rice production in 2025 reached 34.69 million tonnes, up 13.29 per cent. Fisheries exports reached US$6.27 billion, while steel recorded a trade surplus of around US$10.70 billion in January-July 2025. The issue is not whether Indonesia can produce commodities and intermediate goods, but how far we control the value chain beyond them.
The automotive sector is one example. Our steel industry is growing stronger, but the industries that use that steel are not yet fully self-reliant. Automotive imports reached US$8.26 billion in January-September 2025, while imports of components rose by more than 20 per cent. We are becoming better at producing materials, but not yet good enough at making finished goods with components, machinery and technology that we control ourselves.
A similar picture can be seen in healthcare. There are 812 domestic medical-device manufacturers, but 5,661 distributors. Far fewer domestically made products have marketing authorisation than imported products. When around 90 per cent of pharmaceutical raw materials and 88 per cent of medical devices are still imported, it is difficult to say that downstream processing has delivered complete self-reliance.
The risk is that we become a country that is good at selling, but not yet good enough at making. Factories are built here, workers are employed here and products carry Indonesian labels, but raw materials, machinery, components and even key technologies are still determined by overseas supplies. This kind of downstream processing certainly creates added value, but its depth remains limited.
Government policy has begun to address this issue. Health Ministerial Regulation No. 5/2026, for example, encourages the substitution of imported products with domestic ones through the e-catalogue and makes room for products using local raw materials. However, local content will be difficult to increase if the active ingredients themselves still have to be brought in from abroad. Local-content rules mean little if the upstream supply is not available.
We can learn from the payment system. In the first half of 2026, QRIS recorded 12.55 billion transactions, with more than 66 million users and nearly 45 million merchants. In August 2026, BI-FAST processed 549 million transactions worth Rp1,346 trillion. This strength did not result from protection alone, but from national standards, market certainty and room for businesses to innovate.
A model like this should be extended to other strategic sectors. The government does not need to control the entire value chain at once. What matters more is identifying bottlenecks: semiconductors, machinery, pharmaceutical raw materials and strategic components whose disruption could bring multiple sectors to a halt.
Public spending can also provide an anchor. In medicines and medical devices, for example, the government is one of the largest buyers through the public healthcare system. Domestic producers seeking to move up the value chain need a reliable market, not just short-term incentives. Long-term purchasing contracts with clearly defined volumes can give businesses the confidence to build production capacity and technology.
Ultimately, the measure of success for downstream processing needs to be broadened. We should not count only the number of smelters, factories or new projects inaugurated. We should also ask: how long can national production continue if imports are disrupted?
Economic self-reliance is not simply a matter of having many factories. It is the ability to keep production running when the door to imports is no longer wide open. As long as vital foundations such as machinery, chips, raw materials and technology remain in other hands, our self-reliance will still come with conditions.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/economic-self-reliance-must-go-beyond-the-factory-1791773464)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261012083116-14-775201/kemandirian-ekonomi-jangan-berhenti-di-pabrik), translated from Indonesian