East Timor issue
East Timor issue
The article by Dino Patti Djalal, UN statement good deal for
RI, April 25, touched on some problems for Indonesian foreign
policy with regard to East Timor without addressing the
fundamental obstacles which currently prevent a lasting solution
to the dispute.
One problem is that talks to determine the international
status of East Timor involve only the Indonesian and Portuguese
governments without the participation of representatives of the
various Timorese factions. Neither the Indonesian nor the
Portuguese governments can adequately represent the views of the
East Timorese people, since the Indonesian government has too
many extraneous concerns, such as the problem of separatism in
other areas, and the Portuguese government has no major role in
the future of East Timor. Any settlement which they attempt to
impose without the full participation and commitment of the
Timorese community is unlikely to last.
A second problem is that the Indonesian government bases its
claim to legitimate control of East Timor on a law which it
passed in 1976 at the request of an assembly of East Timorese.
However, since all the members of this assembly were selected by
the Indonesian government, its decisions represent the will of
the Indonesian government rather than the will of the Timorese
people. By fixing its claim to sovereignty on such a flimsy
foundation, the Indonesian government gives the impression that
it does not wish to give the people of East Timor a voice in
their own destiny.
A third problem is that anti-integration groups within East
Timor have no political representation. The government plainly
does not want to talk to people in East Timor who oppose
integration: in fact it does not even want to admit that they
exist, except when it has to arrest them. As a result, the
Indonesian Army is condemned to a policy of repression by force,
while separatist Timorese are inevitably attracted to the idea of
rebellion through violence.
A fourth problem is that local and international human rights
groups are not free to investigate and denounce human rights
abuses in East Timor. It is good to know that the Indonesian
government is ready to allow UN representatives to make
occasional visits to East Timor, and that the foreign affairs
ministry is pursuing human rights diplomacy through a policy of
cooperation and openness. But if the government is really keen to
promote human rights, it should allow constant and vigorous
monitoring by nongovernmental human rights organizations, since
this is the best safeguard against human rights abuses. Until
this happens, it will continue to seem that the government sees
the human rights issue chiefly as a battle of propaganda rather
than as a battle for human rights.
If these obstacles can be faced and overcome, a settlement to
the East Timor problem is attainable in a short space of time.
The longer they are avoided, the longer peace for the Timorese
people will be delayed.
JOHN HARGREAVES
Jakarta
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/east-timor-issue-1447893297-1399161)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post