Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

East Jakarta Court Declares Indictment Against Doctor Tifa Null and Void

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
East Jakarta Court Declares Indictment Against Doctor Tifa Null and Void
Image: Media Indonesia

The panel of judges at the East Jakarta District Court (PN Jakarta Timur) has granted the exception filed by the legal team of Tifa Fauziah Tyassuma, or Doctor Tifa, in the case stemming from allegations concerning the diploma of Indonesia’s 7th President, Joko Widodo (Jokowi). In an interim ruling, the judges declared the Public Prosecutor’s indictment null and void, meaning the examination of the merits of the case cannot proceed.

The ruling was read out by Presiding Judge Christina Endarwati at the interim verdict hearing at the East Jakarta District Court.

“In the operative part of the ruling, we declare the objection filed by the defendant’s team of advocates is granted,” the judge said.

The panel also declared the Public Prosecutor’s indictment under Case Register Number PDM/Daftar-133/M.1.14/EOH.2/06/2026, dated 22 June 2026, in the name of defendant Tifa Fauziah Tyassuma, null and void. In addition, the judges ordered that the case file be returned to the Public Prosecutor, with the costs of the case charged to the state.

In its considerations, the panel explained that under Article 206 paragraph (1) of Law Number 20 of 2025 on the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP), the scope of an exception is limited to three matters: the court’s jurisdiction, the inadmissibility of the indictment, or the annulment of the indictment.

The panel then assessed that an indictment must satisfy the material requirements set out in Article 75 paragraph (2) letter B of the KUHAP, namely describing in a careful, clear and complete manner the criminal act charged, along with the time and place of the act. If these requirements are not met, the indictment may be declared null and void.

The judges found that the Public Prosecutor had been careless in drafting the indictment by including two articles governing the same offence, but originating from two different legal regimes, as alternative charges.

“In such a situation, the Public Prosecutor has the freedom to select and determine which alternative articles to charge. However, in determining the articles charged, the material substance of the offences regulated in those alternative articles must be taken into account,” the panel of judges stated in its considerations.

According to the judges, drafting such alternative charges in fact created legal uncertainty, as it showed the Public Prosecutor’s indecision in determining the correct article to charge for the same act.

“Such alternatives will create legal uncertainty, as they suggest that the Public Prosecutor cannot determine which article to charge for the same act. This hesitation in determining the article to be charged shows that the Public Prosecutor has been careless in drafting the indictment,” the judge said.

The panel also affirmed that an indictment must be drafted carefully, clearly and completely so that the defendant can fully understand the act with which they are charged and prepare a defence. If these requirements are not met and the indictment becomes vague or constitutes an obscure libel, the indictment risks being declared null and void.

On these grounds, the panel declared the exception filed by Doctor Tifa’s legal team legally sound and granted it.

As the exception regarding null and void status had been granted, the panel declared that the remaining exception grounds need not be considered. Consequently, the examination of the case cannot proceed, and the case file together with all evidence has been returned to the Public Prosecutor.

Previously, Doctor Tifa had been charged under several articles, including the primary charge under Article 434 paragraph (1) in conjunction with Article 441 paragraph (1) in conjunction with Article 126 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code (KUHP). As a subsidiary charge, she was accused of violating Article 433 paragraph (1) in conjunction with Article 441 paragraph (1) in conjunction with Article 126 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code.

More from 23 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/east-jakarta-court-declares-indictment-against-doctor-tifa-null-and-void-1784782251)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/913862/hakim-pn-jakarta-timur-nyatakan-dakwaan-dokter-tifa-batal-demi-hukum), translated from Indonesian
Print