Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Dradjad Criticises MSCI: High Reputation, but Not Always Right

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Dradjad Criticises MSCI: High Reputation, but Not Always Right
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – Deputy Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs Dradjad Hari Wibowo says Morgan Stanley Capital International (MSCI) assessments are not always right or beneficial to investors, despite the global index provider’s strong reputation.

He urged Indonesian capital-market participants to conduct their own analysis and not to panic after MSCI opened a consultation on downgrading Indonesia from emerging-market to standalone-market status.

“MSCI has a strong reputation, yes. We also need to pay attention to what it says, yes. But there is one thing I want to make clear: it is not always right,” Dradjad told reporters at the Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs office on Friday (16 October 2026).

Dradjad also cited an opinion piece by Ali Masarwah, a fund analyst and managing director of envestor.de, published on the website of Deutsche Börse, the German exchange operator. He said the author found that when the German stock market rose sharply, shares recommended by MSCI performed negatively.

“That means not everything MSCI does benefits investors,” he said. He stressed that his comments were based on analysis, not speculation.

Dradjad added that various simulations showed MSCI index returns were lower than returns elsewhere. He attributed this to the indexes’ concentration in US shares, which account for about 70%, and technology shares, at around 30%, saying the US weighting was too high.

“[There is] too much weight on the United States there,” Dradjad said.

More from 16 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dradjad-criticises-msci-high-reputation-but-not-always-right-1792144268)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20261016142412-17-776919/dradjad-kritisi-msci-reputasi-tinggi-tapi-tak-selalu-benar), translated from Indonesian
Print