DPR Questions Forestry Minister Raja Juli’s Performance as Forest Fires Continue for Three Months
Johan Rosihan, a member of Commission IV of the House of Representatives (DPR) from the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), has questioned Forestry Minister Raja Juli Antoni’s performance in tackling forest and land fires that have continued in Kalimantan and Sumatra for three months.
Johan said Raja Juli was responsible for ensuring that forest areas were properly managed and protected, and that it was reasonable for the public and the DPR to seek an explanation of the response to the fires.
“The Forestry Minister has a major responsibility to ensure that forest areas are properly managed and protected. It is therefore reasonable for the public and the DPR to ask for an explanation of prevention preparedness, response times, the effectiveness of co-ordination and the results of the efforts on the ground,” Johan said on Wednesday (14 October).
He acknowledged, however, that forest and land fires involve several areas of authority. Any assessment should be comprehensive and based on data, including an examination of the roles played by other ministries and agencies, regional governments and business permit holders.
“What is needed now, in my view, is clear operational leadership, measurable steps to protect the public, and accountability for any governance weaknesses that are identified,” he said.
Johan said he was concerned about the fires in Kalimantan and Sumatra. Smoke from the blazes had become a health problem and was disrupting people’s activities.
He said the success of the response should be measured not only by the number of hectares on which fires have been put out, but also by how quickly the state can protect people’s safety and health.
The government must ensure that firefighting operations are co-ordinated under a clear field command, involving the Ministry of Forestry, the Environment Ministry, the National Disaster Mitigation Agency (BNPB), regional governments, the Indonesian Military (TNI), the National Police and all other relevant parties.
“The response must be based on hotspot maps, peatland conditions, the potential spread of fires and the risk of smoke exposure in residential areas. At the same time, the government needs to strengthen health services, provide appropriate masks and clean-air rooms, and offer special protection to children, older people and other vulnerable groups,” he said.
Separately, Sonny T Danaparamita, a Commission IV member from the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P), urged the government to decide promptly on the status and level of the fire disaster.
He said the fires had continued for months, causing casualties, affecting public health, damaging the environment and disrupting social and economic life in various areas. The situation required an immediate clarification of the disaster status and an adequate response.
“The question is whether this should be designated a national disaster, a provincial-level disaster or a regency/city-level disaster, in accordance with the conditions and impact,” Sonny said.
He said that if the fires met the criteria for a national disaster, President Prabowo Subianto should designate them as such without delay. If they did not, the government should publicly explain its reasons and the basis for its assessment, while ensuring that emergency status was set at provincial or regency/city level according to the needs of each area.
“People have been facing a disaster for months. The government must not take too long to determine its status,” he said.
The government has reported that fires were still being extinguished across around 639 hectares of land in six Indonesian provinces: West Kalimantan, Central Kalimantan, South Kalimantan, South Sumatra, Riau and Jambi.
“According to the report from the head of BNPB, around 639 hectares of land are still being extinguished in the six provinces most affected by forest and land fires,” Cabinet Secretary Teddy Indra Wijaya said in a post on the Cabinet Secretariat’s Instagram account after a meeting with President Prabowo and relevant officials on Monday evening (12 October).
Calls for Raja Juli to resign have also emerged. On Monday (12 October), a group of young people staged a protest outside the hotel where Raja Juli was staying in Central Kalimantan.
Aris, a representative of the young people taking part in the protest, openly called on Raja Juli to resign if he could not offer a concrete solution to the fires in Central Kalimantan.
“If you cannot do the job as minister, you might as well resign as Forestry Minister,” Aris shouted during the demonstration.
Aris said tackling the fires should be a priority because their impact was not limited to environmental damage, but also threatened public health and safety. He pointed to the thick haze affecting residents of all ages, including children and older people.
He also questioned the tangible impact of the Forestry Minister’s repeated visits to Central Kalimantan, saying local people had yet to see significant results on the ground.
“He has come to Central Kalimantan several times, but his visits, including today’s, have had virtually no impact at all,” he said.
Aris called on the central government to strengthen its response with more concrete and decisive action. People needed solutions to the fires and haze that continued to disrupt everyday life, he said.
Forestry Minister Raja Juli responded to calls from some quarters for him to resign over the fires in Indonesia, saying he would continue working to address the fires and smoke affecting the public.
“The central and regional governments have deep empathy for people who have been exposed to smoke over the past three months. This motivates us to work even harder. We are certainly not abandoning our responsibilities or washing our hands of the matter,” Raja Juli said on Tuesday (13 October).
He also said he was open to public criticism, which he viewed as useful feedback for the government as it sought to improve its response to the fires.
“We accept criticism and suggestions, even harsh criticism, as vitamins that help us work harder. We need the support of the whole community so that we can face this disaster together,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dpr-questions-forestry-minister-raja-julis-performance-as-forest-fires-continue-for-three-months-1791946275)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261014073307-32-1415047/dpr-soroti-kinerja-menhut-raja-juli-imbas-3-bulan-karhutla-tak-padam), translated from Indonesian