DPR: Effectiveness and Legal Certainty Put Asset Forfeiture Bill to the Test
Jakarta (ANTARA) – Habiburokhman, chairman of Commission III of the House of Representatives (DPR), said that balancing effective asset recovery with guarantees of legal certainty would be a test of statesmanship in drafting the Asset Forfeiture Bill.
He said the bill offered new hope for tackling economic crime in Indonesia. However, experience in other countries showed that simply adopting modern legal instruments developed with international assistance was no guarantee of success.
“Without caution, this instrument could instead become a double-edged sword that erodes legal certainty and democracy,” Habiburokhman said in a written statement received in Jakarta on Monday.
He cited Nigeria, which passed an asset recovery and management law in 2022 adopting non-conviction-based forfeiture (NCB) and a reversal of the burden of proof. However, International Monetary Fund (IMF) records indicate that implementation has been very slow because of limited human resources and unresolved regulatory gaps.
He said that even Ukraine, which received extensive assistance and established an asset management agency called ARMA, had achieved only limited effectiveness. The lack of an adequate data system and breaches of the principle of proportionality had opened opportunities for the agency to abuse its authority.
In his view, repeated failures in various countries underscored an important point: aggressive legal instruments would not work on a fragile institutional foundation.
“Therefore, the design of the Asset Forfeiture Bill must set out strict limits, conditions and exceptional circumstances governing when non-conviction-based forfeiture (NCB) may be applied,” he said.
He said every asset freeze, seizure and forfeiture must be based on clear evidence linking the asset to a crime, and must be subject to independent and effective judicial oversight.
“Ultimately, the drafting of the Asset Forfeiture Bill must rest on meaningful public participation, including in-depth studies of its legal, economic and geopolitical aspects,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dpr-effectiveness-and-legal-certainty-put-asset-forfeiture-bill-to-the-test-1792392674)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5796109/dpr-efektivitas-dan-kepastian-hukum-jadi-ujian-ruu-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian