DPR Commission III on Supreme Court candidate test: If unworthy, we will reject them
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Commission III of the House of Representatives (DPR) has affirmed its objectivity in the fit and proper test for candidates for Supreme Court justices and ad hoc judges for human rights and corruption cases at the Supreme Court.
Commission III member Hinca Pandjaitan, when met at the parliament complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Thursday, said his side would not approve unworthy candidates. “We are sent the names (candidates selected by the Judicial Commission), we study them, we read them. If we believe they are worthy, we proceed. If not, we stop them,” Hinca said in response to ANTARA.
He explained that Commission III has the authority to issue three types of decisions from the fit and proper test results: approving all candidates, approving some, or rejecting all. “Has Commission III ever done that? Yes. We have rejected all, accepted all, and also accepted only some,” he said.
The decision on the results of the fit and proper test for Supreme Court justices and ad hoc judges for human rights and corruption at the Supreme Court will be taken by Commission III on Thursday afternoon.
Hinca’s statement was made in response to criticism from a civil society coalition regarding the selection of Supreme Court justices and ad hoc judges conducted by the Judicial Commission (KY) from March to August 2026.
Previously, the Institute for Judicial Independence Studies and Advocacy (LeIP), Transparency International Indonesia (TII), the Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation (YLBHI), the Indonesia Judicial Research Society (IJRS), the Commission for Missing Persons and Victims of Violence (KontraS), and Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) had submitted several notes. The coalition highlighted, among other things, that the interview stage by the KY was considered too close to the announcement of results. Furthermore, the coalition assessed that the quality of answers from some successful candidates did not meet the minimum quality standards for a Supreme Court judge.
“The KY’s attitude of preferring to pass Supreme Court candidates whose quality and integrity are ‘questionable’ seems to indicate that there is already favouritism and/or preference from the KY for the selection of certain candidates,” the coalition said in its statement on Tuesday (11/8).
Therefore, the civil society coalition urged the DPR to conduct a thorough, objective, and responsible fit and proper test to ensure that the approved Supreme Court candidates truly possess adequate integrity, capacity, and competence.
Meanwhile, KY member Anita Kadir confirmed that the 2026 selection of Supreme Court justices and ad hoc judges was conducted transparently and independently. “Every process has been conveyed to the public, so they can monitor the selection process and follow each stage,” said Anita, who is also the KY spokesperson, in her statement on Tuesday (11/8).
She explained that the KY had involved a number of parties in selecting the candidates. According to her, the selection mechanism has used stages and standards that refer to the competency standards for Supreme Court justices and ad hoc judge candidates at the Supreme Court. “The selection process prioritises the principles of transparency, participation, objectivity, and accountability,” she said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dpr-commission-iii-on-supreme-court-candidate-test-if-unworthy-we-will-reject-them-1786611451)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5692537/komisi-iii-soal-uji-calon-hakim-agung-kalau-tak-layak-kami-hentikan), translated from Indonesian