DPR Commission II Members from 2019–2024 to Meet Over Alleged ‘Gibran Clause’ Smuggling
Guspardi Gaus, a member of the House of Representatives (DPR RI) Commission II during the 2019–2024 term, said former members would meet again to discuss the alleged insertion of a ‘Gibran-specific clause’ into the General Elections Commission (KPU) regulation setting the requirements for candidates in the 2024 presidential election.
The provision in question is Article 18(3) of KPU Regulation No. 19/2023. The allegation that it had been inserted without proper discussion emerged during a Constitutional Court (MK) hearing challenging the validity of Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s diploma.
Guspardi said the plan for former Commission II members to meet and discuss the article was proposed by current commission member Ahmad Doli Kurnia. Doli chaired Commission II when the House and the KPU discussed the regulation ahead of the 2024 presidential election.
“Perhaps we’ll meet in the coming weeks to examine it. That’s straightforward; the records of every hearing are available,” Guspardi told reporters by phone on Tuesday (13 October).
Guspardi said there were at least two possible explanations for how the article could have passed through discussions between the KPU and Commission II. First, it may not have been included in the list of provisions discussed with the House. Alternatively, it may have been included but not actually discussed.
“It may not have been included among the provisions or policy changes under consideration. Or it may have been included in the discussion papers but not mentioned, and then somehow became part of the accumulated outcome of all the discussions,” Guspardi said.
He said that if the article had been discussed at the meeting, it would have surprised many people. Instead, it had prompted no reaction at the time.
“If this had been part of what was consulted on, journalists would certainly have been surprised. I would have raised an uproar too. Why did something happen differently from the way other matters are handled? What was going on?” said the politician from the National Mandate Party (PAN).
Guspardi said regulations and legislation discussed in the House should also undergo public consultation to receive feedback from the public. He alleged that no such consultation was held for the ‘Gibran-specific clause’.
“Every KPU regulation should undergo public consultation. What are the public’s responses, suggestions and input? Various groups have already said that no public consultation on this issue ever took place,” he said.
He therefore believes Article 18(3) of the regulation was never discussed at a meeting with Commission II.
Guspardi’s view is consistent with that of Ahmad Doli Kurnia, who chaired Commission II during the 2019–2024 term. Doli has also said he believes the article was not discussed.
“If the chair, Doli, says it was never discussed, that convinces me. He was the one who received the letter and the documents, chaired the meeting and led the drafting of its conclusions,” Guspardi said.
He added that Doli had announced the meeting’s conclusions openly and transparently, with various parties present.
“He read out the conclusions and sought views on the wording, including from Commission II members, the ministries, the KPU, the Elections Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu) and the Election Organisers’ Ethics Council (DKPP). The process was open and transparent, and the matter was decided through deliberation and consensus,” he said.
Guspardi also responded to former KPU chair Hasyim Asy’ari, who has denied that the article was smuggled into the regulation. Hasyim, who was KPU chair during the discussions, previously claimed that Commission II knew about the provision and should therefore share responsibility.
Guspardi said Commission II would not be responsible if the article had indeed been inserted without proper discussion.
“Responsibility would be shared only if the provision had been discussed, deliberated and agreed upon, and then included in the joint conclusions. Only then would it be a shared duty and responsibility—not just for the KPU commission, but also for DPR Commission II,” he said.
The disagreement between former Commission II chair Ahmad Doli Kurnia and former KPU chair Hasyim Asy’ari concerns Article 18(3) of the regulation, which was seen as allowing Gibran Rakabuming to run as vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 election. Doli said he did not know about the article, while Hasyim disputed this and said it appeared in the draft regulation approved as a conclusion of a hearing.
The term ‘Gibran-specific clause’ was first used by one of the lawyers for the petitioners challenging Gibran’s diploma at the Constitutional Court, Bambang Widjojanto.
The Constitutional Court ruled that it could not accept the petition filed by Denny Indrayana and others because the applicants lacked legal standing. However, in its reasoning, the Court said that the proceedings had not established the existence of a valid document showing that Gibran’s high-school diploma, or an equivalent certificate of completion, had been used to register him as a vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 election.
The Court said that an equivalency certificate issued by the relevant ministry on the basis of a certificate of attendance and an academic transcript was not a diploma or certificate of completion.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dpr-commission-ii-members-from-2019-2024-to-meet-over-alleged-gibran-clause-smuggling-1791967867)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261014142146-32-1415230/komisi-ii-dpr-2019-2024-akan-kumpul-bahas-selundupan-pasal-gibran), translated from Indonesian