DPD Requests Agrarian Reform Bill to Include Special Provisions for Papua Indigenous Peoples' Protection
Filep Wamafma, a member of the Regional Representative Council (DPD) from West Papua, emphasised that the discussion of the Agrarian Reform Bill must serve as a corrective instrument against land ownership inequality, structural agrarian conflicts, and state policies that potentially ignore indigenous rights.
This is crucial for Papua, given that the Papua Special Autonomy Law (UU Otsus Papua) provides a specific mandate to recognise, respect, protect, empower, and develop the rights of indigenous peoples, including both communal (ulayat) and individual rights. The Special Autonomy Law also requires deliberation and agreement from indigenous law communities regarding the provision of communal land for various purposes.
“In my view, the Agrarian Reform Bill must explicitly strengthen, rather than diminish, the standards of protection provided by the Papua Special Autates Law. For example, by including a Special Chapter on agrarian reform in the special autonomy regions of Papua,” said Filep in a statement on Thursday (10/9).
“In detail, the implementation of Agrarian Reform in Papua Province must observe, respect, protect, and strengthen the rights of indigenous law communities and the special status guaranteed in the laws regarding Papua’s Special Autonomy,” he added.
He asserted that communal land rights (hak ulayat) must be recognised as ancestral rights, rather than merely being objects of agrarian reform. The Bill must clearly distinguish between state-redistributed land and ancestral territories that are already held based on ancestral rights.
“Ancestral territories should not automatically be included as Land Objects of Agrarian Reform (TORA) simply because they lack individual certificates. The absence of a certificate cannot be interpreted as the absence of a right. This must be taken into account,” he said.
Furthermore, the Agrarian Reform Bill needs to establish that before the government issues rights, permits, concessions, or projects that impact ancestral territories, it must prioritise identification, verification, recognition of indigenous communities, mapping of territories, determination of rights, and consultation. This step is considered vital to prevent structural conflicts resulting from concessions issued over unsettled land statuses.
Regarding National Strategic Projects (PSN), Filep encouraged the operational implementation of the principle of Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC). Approval from indigenous communities must be free from pressure, provided before decisions are implemented, documented, and allow for the right to reject or request changes to plans that have serious impacts.
“More deeply, the Bill must mandate the government to build an integrated National Agrarian and Ancestral Territory Information System. At a minimum, it should include indigenous law communities, ancestral territory boundaries, communal rights, individual indigenous land, customary forests, permits/concessions, HGU/HPL, forest areas, mining areas, PSN, and agrarian conflicts. For instance, one plot of land must have one clear legal status and there must be no overlapping control. This is because overlapping authority and concessions are currently a highlighted issue in the Bill’s discussion,” he noted.
The alumnus of Law from Hasanuddin University, Makassar, added that the Bill must guarantee the rights of indigenous peoples to demand land return, restoration of rights, compensation, and livelihood recovery if ancestral territories are proven to have been transferred unlawfully.
The working procedures of the National Agrarian Reform Agency (BRAN) also came under scrutiny to ensure they can accommodate the interests of indigenous communities.
“Therefore, there must be strict limitations; BRAN must respect Papua’s special authority and cannot determine or change the status of communal rights without the mechanisms specified in the Special Autonomy Law and its implementing regulations,” he said.
He added that a thorough conflict resolution mechanism is required through the identification of root causes, verification of possession, mapping, permit audits, as well as restitution and livelihood recovery.
“Agrarian Reform must be a reform, not merely land administration. For Papua, Agrarian Reform must be an instrument to strengthen Special Autonomy, recognise the ancestral rights of indigenous peoples, protect communal rights, resolve past conflicts, and ensure that development does not eliminate the living space of indigenous communities,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dpd-requests-agrarian-reform-bill-to-include-special-provisions-for-papua-indigenous-peoples-protection-1789098816)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/932230/dpd-minta-ruu-reforma-agraria-muat-pasal-khusus-perlindungan-masyarakat-adat-papua), translated from Indonesian