Don't shoot the messengers
Don't shoot the messengers
The first casualty when war comes is Truth, pronounced U.S.
Sen. Hiram Johnson back in 1917.
In the case of the war in Aceh, truth has become the second
casualty after education, following the torching of hundreds of
schools in the first week after martial law was imposed.
As we moved into the 10th day of the war, there are disturbing
signs that journalists, whose job it is to report the Truth as
far as possible, have become the target of shooting, both
literally and figuratively speaking.
On the ground, some journalists have become targets of
unidentified gunmen. Although no journalist has been killed, the
shootings are clearly intended to harass and intimidate.
The media have also come under fire from a different front.
The Indonesian Military (TNI) and the government have been
invoking national unity in urging, or even coercing, the
Indonesian media to support the military campaign in Aceh.
One Army general even reportedly told the media to do away
with the principle of covering both sides, and to just report
from the perspective or interests of the government.
Koran Tempo is now the target of a planned lawsuit by the
military for its report about the killing of villagers, including
a 13-year old, whom soldiers insisted were GAM members.
The military command in Aceh, the highest authority under the
martial law, has ordered Aceh media not to quote statements made
by the separatist Aceh Free Movement (GAM). By invoking the power
granted under martial law, the military is reportedly considering
more media restrictions, possibly expelling foreign journalists
and other journalists not accredited with the TNI.
Truth actually has already become a casualty of the war
without journalists getting shot at, or without the media being
bullied into submission, either by the government or by GAM.
Any war, or any conflict, by definition is difficult to cover
by even the most experienced and skilled journalists. But that
should not in any way stop us in the media from trying to conduct
our job as effectively as possible. Many brave reporters who are
truly committed to their profession have stayed on in Aceh to try
to report as truthfully as conditions allow.
Embedded journalism is certainly a welcome experiment. It
gives journalists additional access to information. Its main
shortcoming, that it gives only one-sided information, could be
compensated by having journalists covering the other side too.
It should be noted that the presence of independent
journalists was crucial to ensure that this does not turn into a
dirty war. The chief interests of mainstream media is the fate of
civilians caught in the crossfire. War, under any pretext, is a
humanitarian tragedy. The presence of media ensures that these
civilians do not need to suffer more than they need to, and that
both sides to the war observe some basic rules of engagement.
With that in mind, both sides in the war have a duty to ensure
that the journalists's search for truth should go unimpeded. Both
must guarantee the safety of journalists. Given the difficult
terrain, we may not always get it right, but that should not stop
us from trying to get as near as possible to the truth.
Grasping the truth for the media is already difficult in the
midst of the propaganda war waged by the government and GAM.
Modern wars are always waged on two fronts: on the ground and
through the media. The latter is just as important as the first.
For the Indonesian government, the propaganda war is crucial
to win the hearts and minds of the people in Aceh, to secure
domestic public support, and equally important, to sustain the
support of the international community. If there was ever a
valuable lesson that we learned from East Timor, it was that
Jakarta neglected the international community and paid dearly
when the whole world turned completely against Indonesia.
Since the Indonesian government and the TNI are not known for
their sophistication in handling "psychological operations" to
manipulate the flow of news, the best thing they can do in Aceh
is to be open and transparent, and let journalists, local and
foreign, go about their business in digging out the Truth.
Having won the high moral ground before the start of the war,
with all these talks of openness, inviting embedded journalists,
and promising a minimum of civilian casualties, the TNI is about
to squander the goodwill that it has built, by trying to impose
restrictions on the media or intimidating them.
Let's hope that these measures came from poor advice or
ignorance, and not because the TNI has something horrible it
wants to hide from the public.
The moment the TNI starts shooting journalists, either
literally and figuratively, is the moment when it starts losing
the propaganda war. And we know that, based on our experience in
East Timor a few years ago, how costly that could be.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dont-shoot-the-messengers-1447893297-1355400)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post