Does Internationalisation Increase the Value of Family Firms? Using CEO Attributes as a Moderating Variable
A family firm is a business “in which the family controls the business through significant involvement in ownership and management positions” (Mondal & Lahiri, 2000; D’Angelo et al., 2016). Family businesses are among the largest companies in every region globally (De Massis et al., 2018; Xu et al., 2020). They represent 33% of companies in the United States and 40% of companies in France and Germany with annual revenues exceeding $1 billion. They are even more prevalent in developing markets, accounting for around 55% of large companies in India and South-East Asia and 46% in Brazil (see Figure 1).
Figure 1: Family Businesses Are More Prevalent Among Top Companies in Emerging Markets. Sources: Capital market data for various countries; BCG analysis. Companies with annual revenue of more than $1 billion. Top 200 companies by revenue. Companies with annual revenue of more than $500 million.
In the long term, family firms face many challenges in order to survive and grow. One challenge posed by ever-increasing globalisation and worldwide competition is the strategic choice to seek new growth opportunities beyond national borders (Pukall & Calabrò, 2014). As a result, some family firms decide to pursue ambitious international growth paths, while others remain domestic (De Massis et al., 2018).
Internationalisation can be a strategy for family firms to achieve competitiveness and long-term growth, as this strategy revitalises both family and business, ensuring business continuity and new opportunities for the next generation of the family (Arregle et al., 2012; Calabrò, Brogi & Torchia, 2016; Claver et al., 2009; De Massis et al., 2018; Alayo et al., 2023). However, an internationalisation strategy also brings uncertainty, greater task complexity and higher costs (Debrulle & Maes, 2015; Fernández & Nieto, 2006; Hsu et al., 2013; Rienda & Andreu, 2021). It remains debated among researchers whether the phenomenon of internationalisation demonstrates that its benefits outweigh the costs incurred. This paper therefore attempts to explore further whether internationalisation activities in family firms can increase firm value, or whether the opposite holds. Firm value (FV) is the book value or market value of a company. Firm value also reflects investors’ perception of achieved financial performance as mirrored in the market share price.
This research uses a sample from a developing country, namely Indonesia, located in South-East Asia and recorded as a region with a majority of family firms (Figure 1). Developing markets present a different context for running family businesses, for instance in terms of regulation, institutions and contract law. Moreover, families in developing markets are often much larger, more cohesive and more respectful of hierarchy than families in developed markets. In studying how family involvement in managing their businesses has changed over the past 200 years, analysis by Boston Consulting Group found that in developed markets, family involvement has generally declined over time. As non-family members have entered to manage increasingly complex organisations, the status of family members has evolved from owner-managers, to owner-investors (who continue to participate in major decisions), to passive investors. The opposite has occurred in developing markets, where families have become more actively involved in their businesses.
Note Figure 2, which shows that in developing markets families have become more involved in their businesses over time. High involvement is when a family member is the CEO or chief executive, or family members hold senior executive positions. Moderate involvement is when a family member is the chief executive and active on the board of directors, but family members do not hold senior executive positions. Low involvement is when family members are investors without significant managerial involvement. The width of each bar reflects the relative number of companies in the sample for that age range.
This phenomenon underpins our introduction of family involvement through the CEO and their attributes as a moderating variable, to help analyse the important role of the highest decision-maker in the company and to allow us to study their role in enhancing family firm value through internationalisation activities. As is widely known, the CEO plays a crucial role in deciding whether or not internationalisation activities are undertaken within the company. From the perspective of upper echelon theory (UET), an important antecedent of major strategic decisions such as internationalisation appears to be CEO attributes (Varela et al., 2024; Popli et al., 2022; Ramón-Llorens et al., 2017).
Figure 2: Family Involvement in Companies.
Although the financial performance and valuation of family firms appear thematically close and closely related, the topic of family firm value has received less attention in prior research (Tao-Schuchardt et al., 2023). Most previous studies have investigated the internationalisation-performance relationship in the context of internal organisational capabilities or industry effects, but few have examined the moderating effects of top executive characteristics. Our study addresses these issues and offers a more nuanced and dynamic relationship. While previous studies have focused on examining the moderating role of exogenous factors (for example, culture and institutions) and endogenous factors (for example, product diversification, size and firm-specific assets) on the relationship between internationalisation and performance (Li, 2007; Hitt et al., 2006; Althaf), executive attributes have received little attention. We argue that CEOs’ attributes influence corporate implementation and information processing related to internationalisation, which in turn moderate the aforementioned benefits and costs of firm internationalisation. We seek to build a framework explaining how internationalisation activities in family firms affect firm value, focusing on the role of the family CEO and their attributes, which can weaken or strengthen the influence of internationalisation on firm value.
We conducted tests using data on family firms listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange from 2015 to 2023. The research comprises 1,417 observations. We used ordinary least squares analysis to answer the research questions. The results show that internationalisation has a positive effect on family firm value. In addition, the presence of a family member as CEO strengthens the relationship between internationalisation and firm value, as do other CEO attributes such as education level, international experience and gender. Meanwhile, CEO tenure and age weaken the relationship between internationalisation and firm performance. This occurs because family firms are typically companies with a long-term orientation. Internationalisation becomes a choice for family firms to realise their long-term objectives. We also found that the relationship weakens when the company has a CEO with a high level of education, long tenure, older age and international experience. We also conducted a robustness analysis using a three-year lag between the dependent and independent variables. This analysis continued to find that internationalisation is positively associated with long-term performance. Additional analysis shows that internationalisation is positively associated with short-term performance in family firms.
Accordingly, this research adds insights to the international business literature in the following ways. First, unlike previous research on the relationship between internationalisation and performance, which has mostly focused on samples from developed countries, this study focuses on companies in developing markets, because family-owned and family-controlled business groups constitute the majority of business groups in developing markets (Cuervo-Cazurra, 2006; Yildirim-Öktem & Selekler-Ökşen, 2018). Our study also contributes to research on the internationalisation of business groups. Second, this paper contributes to the literature on firm value (for example, Fahlenbrach & Stulz, 2009; Basu et al., 2016; Cremers et al., 2017; Napapor & Chaiporn) by providing additional empirical insight into how foreign investment can explain variation in firm value. Firm value also reflects long-term performance within companies. We argue that long-term performance is a more accurate measure than those used in previous research for two reasons. First, it more tightly captures the consequences of rapid internationalisation than accounting measures, which have a short-term orientation. Second, it is a better proxy for future growth prospects than survival measures, which do not distinguish between profitable investments.
These findings contribute, particularly for family firms, by showing that pursuing internationalisation can lead to improvements in both short-term and long-term company performance. On the other hand, CEO characteristics moderate the relationship between internationalisation and firm performance. These results can also be used as a consideration for shareholders when appointing a company’s CEO. In this way, this research extends our knowledge of internationalisation and firm performance.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/does-internationalisation-increase-the-value-of-family-firms-using-ceo-attributes-as-a-moderating-variable-1788843017)
Originally published by unair.ac.id (https://unair.ac.id/apakah-internasionalisasi-meningkatkan-nilai-perusahaan-keluarga-menggunakan-atriut-ceo-sebagai-variabel-moderasi-dengan-bukti-empiris-di-indonesia/), translated from Indonesian