Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Doctor Internships, Intergenerational Communication, and Our Healthcare System

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Doctor Internships, Intergenerational Communication, and Our Healthcare System
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Various events that have emerged recently regarding the Indonesian Doctor Internship Programme have attracted public attention. Diverse views have surfaced, ranging from issues of participant welfare, workload, and protection, to the quality of mentorship in healthcare facilities. Amidst these polemics, there is one thing we need to view more clearly. These events actually provide an opportunity for all stakeholders to reflect on the system that has been running so far. No system is perfect, and neither is the healthcare system. As an ecosystem involving the government, professional organisations, educational institutions, hospitals, community health centres (puskesmas), supervising doctors, and internship participants, there is always room for evaluation and improvement. Therefore, the question we need to ask is no longer who is at fault. The more important question is: what can we improve together?

Why Does the Internship Remain Important? The Indonesian Doctor Internship Programme is part of an effort to improve the quality of medical graduates and patient safety. This programme is designed as a transition period from the world of education to the real world of healthcare services. It is during this phase that a doctor learns to integrate scientific knowledge, clinical skills, professional ethics, communication abilities, and decision-making in real situations. In many countries, this kind of transition phase is an important part of forming the professionalism of healthcare workers. The goal is not only to produce doctors capable of performing medical procedures, but also doctors who are professionally mature and ready to face the complexities of healthcare services. The scale of this programme is not small. In DKI Jakarta Province alone, for the 2025-2026 period, there are 108 Indonesian Doctor Internship Programme (PIDI) sites with 562 participants, and 27 Indonesian Dentist Internship Programme (PIDGI) sites with 78 participants. This programme is supported by more than one hundred supervising doctors serving in various hospitals and puskesmas. This means the quality of internship implementation concerns not only the interests of individual participants, but also the quality of future doctor formation and the healthcare services the public will receive. Therefore, when various problems arise in its implementation, what needs to be fixed is the quality of its execution, not the fundamental spirit of the programme.

An Often-Overlooked Issue: Communication. On several occasions, the author has served as a resource person in coaching activities for internship supervising doctors within the DKI Jakarta Provincial Health Office. From the various discussions that took place, one interesting common thread emerged. Many internship problems, it turns out, are not solely rooted in clinical competence. Problems often arise from communication. Differing expectations, unclear instructions, ineffective feedback, misunderstandings in interpreting directions, or overly hierarchical relationships that make participants reluctant to ask questions. Monitoring and evaluation findings conducted by the DKI Jakarta Provincial Health Office show that various complaints that arise are not only related to welfare and workload, but also concern poor mentoring functions and communication. On the other hand, evaluations by supervising doctors also show complaints regarding discipline, initiative, professional ethics, and participant compliance with various learning obligations. These findings indicate that internship problems cannot be viewed in black and white. Both parties face real challenges. Therefore, the solution needed is not mutual blame, but improving the quality of communication and learning. In the world of healthcare, communication is not merely a soft skill. Communication is part of clinical competence. Communication errors can affect the learning process, team coordination, and even patient safety.

When Two Generations Meet. We also cannot ignore the fact that today’s internship takes place in the context of generational change. Most supervising doctors were shaped by an educational culture that was relatively hierarchical and instructive. They grew up in an environment that placed seniority as an important part of the learning process. Meanwhile, the majority of current intern doctors come from Generation Z, who grew up in the digital era. They are accustomed to fast access to information, receiving direct feedback, and are more comfortable with dialogue than one-way instruction. Various global studies on Generation Z show that they tend to value open communication, collaboration, and clarity of feedback in both learning and working processes. These differences are not a problem. However, without good communication, these differences can develop into a perception gap. Supervising doctors feel participants lack initiative. Participants feel supervisors are difficult to approach. Supervisors feel they have explained. Participants feel they have not understood. The message conveyed is the same, but the meaning received is different. This is where communication becomes a determining factor.

The Importance of Psychological Safety. One concept widely discussed in the world of modern education and organisations is psychological safety. Amy Edmondson of Harvard Business School defines it as a condition where a person feels safe to ask questions, express opinions, admit mistakes, or ask for help without fear of being humiliated or punished. Edmondson’s research shows that teams with a high level of psychological safety have better learning capabilities because team members dare to discuss

More from 14 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/doctor-internships-intergenerational-communication-and-our-healthcare-system-1781409041)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260614091558-14-742657/internship-dokter-komunikasi-antar-generasi-dan-sistem-kesehatan-kita), translated from Indonesian
Print