Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Doctor Income Standards: Is It Necessary?

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Doctor Income Standards: Is It Necessary?
Image: Media Indonesia

There is interesting news in the medical world. The Executive Board of the Indonesian Medical Association (PB ID/IDI) recently proposed a minimum income standard (take-home pay) for doctors, especially those working in government health facilities. The figures are substantial: general practitioners in community health centres (puskesmas) at approximately Rp34.8 million per month, general practitioners in hospitals at Rp30.8 million, and specialists at around Rp110.9 million per month. For doctors working in outermost, frontier, and island regions, the IDI proposes an additional increment of at least 50%.

This news immediately triggered public reaction. Some feel the standards and figures are excessive, especially when compared to the average wage of Indonesian workers. Various questions have emerged: does Indonesia need to have income standards for doctors? Is the income of Indonesian doctors indeed low enough to require standardisation? What are the potential effects of this standardisation, particularly on the quality of service and the distribution of doctors?

Beyond Standard Rights

So far, the health and medical sectors have been filled with various standards. There are standards for medical competence, service standards, patient safety standards, hospital accreditation standards, and even standards for how long a doctor’s education must take. Strangely, when it comes to determining a fair economic value for a doctor’s work, the system becomes vague. To date, there has been no income standard for healthcare workers, including doctors. A clear inequality is evident. Regarding obligations, there are many standards; regarding rights, there are none. This is one reason why income standards are necessary.

Furthermore, a doctor’s work is not a job whose value can only be calculated based on the number of working hours or the number of patients examined. A doctor does not merely sell ‘time spent examining patients’. Behind one hour of a doctor’s work lies professional and specialised labour involving long educational backgrounds, continuously updated competencies, legal responsibilities, professional risks, and clinical decisions involving life and death. Doctor remuneration should take all these factors into account. Otherwise, the recognition of these professional determinants will be neglected. The existence of income standards would not only reclaim long-neglected rights but also uphold the concept of justice in assessing professional work.

There is an assumption that doctors’ incomes in Indonesia are low. This argument needs to be discussed clearly. Generally, it is too simplistic to conclude that all Indonesian doctors are ‘paid low’. The situation is highly heterogeneous. There is a difference between specialists and general practitioners, just as there is a difference between doctors in large urban hospitals with additional private practices and doctors in remote regency health centres. However, generally, the income of Indonesian doctors can be scrutinised through the income of general practitioners, who make up about 70% of all doctors. And the picture is indeed unpromising. A survey shows that with an average of 42 working hours per week, more than 26% of general practitioners earn less than Rp3 million per month, and only about 10% receive more than Rp10.5 million. Even recently, full-time general practitioner vacancies have been found with salary offers of less than Rp5 million per month. This is distressing. Therefore, it is quite reasonable that the profession of a doctor should have a minimum remuneration standard that reflects their competence, workload, and professional responsibility.

A Tool for Distribution Equality

Indonesia faces a classic problem: uneven distribution of doctors, which ultimately leads to doctor shortages. The density of doctors in Jakarta is dozens of times higher compared to the density in West Sulawesi and Papua. As of May 2025, there are still 424 community health centres, primarily outside Java, that do not have doctors. The problem with specialists is even more severe. The WHO reported in March 2026 that only 78.1% of government hospitals have a complete set of the seven basic types of specialist doctors. So, will increasing income cause doctors to flock to the regions and resolve this maldistribution and deficiency?

We often view this problem solely as a matter of ‘doctors not wanting to go to the regions’. However, from a labour perspective, the question should be reversed: what is the system offering so that doctors are willing to come and stay in the regions?

There are many reasons why doctors are reluctant to work in remote areas. Income is a very important determinant. Generally, the economic opportunities for doctors in rural areas are more limited than in large cities, while the challenges of living and working are actually heavier. In cities, doctors have access to more complete health facilities, better access to education and transport, schools for children, job opportunities for spouses, and opportunities for additional private practice. In remote areas, many of these advantages are reduced or even unavailable. Implementing income standards can provide economic certainty that working in the regions does not mean having to accept an income below a decent standard.

Furthermore, the IDI’s proposal does not stop at setting income standards. It also includes the idea that doctors working in difficult areas should receive higher compensation. Economically, this approach has a strong foundation. This principle is known as ‘compensating wage differential’: jobs with greater discomfort, risk, remoteness, or opportunity cost need to be balanced with higher compensation. Therefore, the IDI’s proposal to provide an additional at least 50% to doctors working in difficult areas is quite rational. In fact, for very remote areas, the issue might not be whether an additional 50% is too large, but whether that figure is sufficient to offset all the consequences of working and living there.

It is true that the issue of doctor distribution cannot be solved…

More from 14 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/doctor-income-standards-is-it-necessary-1789339864)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/kolom-pakar/933033/standar-pendapatan-dokter-perlukah), translated from Indonesian
Print