Do Not Just Put Out the Fires—Seize the Assets of Forest Arsonists
In Indonesia, burning forests can be a shortcut to economic gain. It reduces land-clearing costs and accelerates business expansion, while the environmental damage and suffering of local communities become burdens borne by the state. Even after the fires are put out, the profits from these illegal activities may remain intact.
This is the greatest irony of our environmental law enforcement. The state spends public funds to extinguish fires, communities bear the health and economic losses, yet those who profit from forest burning may still retain their wealth.
Not all forest and land fires are deliberate. But when burning is planned for economic gain, it should no longer be regarded merely as an environmental offence. It is a crime that uses ecological destruction as a means of making money. Unfortunately, Indonesia’s legal approach remains too focused on punishing offenders rather than removing the profits obtained through crime.
Yet crimes driven by economic gain cannot be effectively stopped while those gains can still be retained. The debate on the Asset Forfeiture Bill should therefore be an opportunity for Commission III of the House of Representatives (DPR RI) to strengthen law enforcement against environmental crime, particularly forest and land fires involving corporate interests.
When court judgments are not enough
Indonesia is not short of legal instruments to punish forest burning. Law No. 32 of 2009 on Environmental Protection and Management provides for criminal penalties, administrative sanctions and civil liability. The problem lies in the effectiveness of enforcement and the state’s ability to reach assets connected to criminal acts.
A court ruling ordering a company to pay environmental damages does not automatically ensure that the money will be recovered. When assets are spread among affiliated companies, held through layers of ownership or moved through difficult-to-trace transactions, recovery can face serious obstacles. The result is a gap between the state’s victory in court and its success in recovering environmental losses.
This problem is more complex in corporate crime because those who carry out the acts directly are not necessarily those who enjoy the greatest profits. A worker may be held responsible for burning, while the economic gains flow to a wider business structure. The law must be able to distinguish between direct perpetrators, decision-makers and economic beneficiaries.
Otherwise, enforcement will reach only the lowest rung of the criminal chain, while the economic incentives that drive it remain. A legal system that punishes those who start fires but fails to confiscate their illegal profits risks turning criminal penalties into no more than an additional cost of doing business—and will ultimately cause serious, lasting harm to Indonesia.
The United States, Britain and Brazil: three lessons for Indonesia
A number of countries have developed approaches linking environmental law enforcement with financial accountability. The United States, Britain and Brazil offer relevant lessons, although each has a different legal system and set of mechanisms.
In the United States, environmental enforcement does not rely solely on prison sentences. Through co-operation between the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of Justice (DOJ), cases can involve fines, restitution, remediation and, where the law permits, forfeiture of criminal proceeds.
In its fiscal year 2025 report, the EPA recorded more than US$600 million in fines, restitution and remediation under court judgments, as well as more than US$1 billion in forfeited illegal proceeds. These figures show that environmental enforcement can produce tangible financial consequences, rather than focusing only on the punishment of individuals.
A different approach can be found in Britain through the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (POCA). The Act provides for the confiscation of criminal proceeds after conviction, as well as civil recovery of property shown to have been obtained unlawfully in certain circumstances without requiring a prior criminal conviction. These mechanisms allow authorities to trace assets concealed through company structures, trusts or cross-border ownership.
The Crime and Policing Act 2026 reforms have further strengthened forfeiture mechanisms, including efforts to preserve assets from the investigation stage and improve the enforcement of court orders. The message from Britain is clear: successful law enforcement must not stop at a court judgment. The state must ensure that criminal proceeds are actually recovered.
Brazil, meanwhile, offers a closer comparison with Indonesia as a country with extensive tropical forests. Its Environmental Crimes Law, Law No. 9,605/1998, provides for the seizure of instruments used in environmental offences.
In July 2026, Brazil’s Superior Tribunal de Justiça (Superior Court of Justice) affirmed that confiscating heavy equipment used in environmental offences does not always require proof that its owner acted in bad faith. However, legal procedures and the owner’s opportunity to defend their interests must still be respected. The ruling reflects a determination to prevent instruments of economic activity from being used again to damage the environment.
The three countries do not apply identical systems. The United States emphasises criminal enforcement and financial consequences; Britain provides a broad framework for recovering criminal proceeds; and Brazil strengthens action against the instruments used to destroy the environment. But all three offer a principle Indonesia should consider: environmental crime cannot be addressed simply by punishing people.
The state must also be able to reach the assets, instruments and illegal profits connected with such crimes. Indonesian law needs to address this urgently. The Asset Forfeiture Bill is a prime opportunity to reform efforts to prevent and address forest fires.
These international lessons should be central to Commission III of the DPR’s deliberations on the Asset Forfeiture Bill. Indonesia needs an approach that breaks the link between environmental crime and economic gain. At least three reforms should be pursued.
First, ensure that the proceeds of environmental crime—including illegal profits from forest burning—can be reached through effective asset-forfeiture mechanisms. Where forest burning is proven to have been carried out for economic gain, authorities should be able to trace the proceeds of the crime, not merely seize the equipment used to start the fire. Non-conviction-based asset forfeiture could be considered in certain circumstances where criminal proceedings cannot continue, provided there is sufficient evidence, judicial oversight and protection for third-party rights.
Second, strengthen beneficial-ownership transparency and authorities’ ability to trace corporate transactions. Legal entities must not be abused to conceal criminal proceeds. Where there is evidence that a controller or beneficial owner used a company to commit a crime or hide its proceeds, the law should provide mechanisms to hold that person accountable. However, share ownership or a position on a company’s board must not, by itself, provide grounds for confiscating personal assets. The link between the assets, the unlawful conduct and the responsible party must be proved.
Third, put victims and environmental recovery at the centre of decisions on the use of forfeited assets. The state should establish transparent mechanisms for using proceeds to restore ecosystems, rehabilitate peatland and support communities affected by forest and land fires. These policies must be accountable, so that asset forfeiture does not become merely a means of increasing state revenue. These three priorities give Commission III an opportunity to show that legal reform is not just about expanding authorities’ powers, but also about improving enforcement and protecting communities.
The DPR must act decisively: legislate against forest and land fires
The problem of forest and land fires is ultimately about more than weak forest monitoring. It also concerns the state’s willingness to confront the economic incentives that drive environmental destruction. Every time a fire breaks out, communities suffer substantial losses. Children lose the chance to learn in a healthy environment, residents face the threat of respiratory illness, and economic activity is disrupted.
If illegal profits remain in the hands of offenders, there is no guarantee that the cycle will not repeat. Commission III of the DPR must therefore not allow the Asset Forfeiture Bill to become merely a legislative trophy.
The law must be designed as an instrument capable of breaking the link between crime and profit, including in environmental offences. Asset forfeiture does not mean that the state may take someone’s wealth without due process. Precisely because these powers are substantial, they must be subject to clear evidential standards, judicial oversight and protection of constitutional rights. But legal caution must not become an excuse for allowing illegal profits to remain protected.
The state must not be willing to punish only the person who lights the fire, while lacking the resolve to trace those who profit from it. The success of environmental law reform cannot be measured solely by the number of suspects arrested or judgments handed down. It must be measured by the state’s ability to recover losses, restore communities’ rights and ensure that crime is no longer economically rewarding.
Commission III of the DPR has an opportunity to drive this change by establishing a strong, proportionate Asset Forfeiture Law that serves the public interest. As long as forests can be burned for profit and the proceeds remain safely in offenders’ hands, the state has not truly won its fight against environmental crime.
Do not just put out the fires. Seize the profits that lie behind the suffering they cause.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/do-not-just-put-out-the-fires-seize-the-assets-of-forest-arsonists-1793505090)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8733163/jangan-hanya-padamkan-api-rampas-aset-pembakar-hutan), translated from Indonesian