Do Not Hide Behind the Mask of Religion
No parent sends their child to an Islamic boarding school with suspicion. They come entrusting their children with hope and confidence that they will grow in an environment that teaches knowledge, shapes morals, and builds civility. Therefore, every time news of violence emerges from a religious educational setting, it is not only the victims and their families who are hurt. There is another wound we must recognise: the fracturing of public trust. Rebuilding that trust is far more difficult than preserving it from the start. Such incidents must not merely become news that provokes momentary anger. They must serve as material for collective reflection. When spaces expected to build character instead produce violence, there is something we must fix, not only in the perpetrators but also in our way of safeguarding the mandate.
Similar problems are not exclusive to Islamic boarding schools. We have witnessed fraud in the name of sharia, investment schemes selling religious symbols, misuse of public funds, and various forms of religious services that prioritise profit over devotion. The forms may differ, but the pattern is the same: public trust is exploited for purposes that in no way reflect religious values. No religion teaches violence. No religion justifies fraud. No religion makes room for the abuse of trust. Therefore, any attempt to use religion as a shield or a mask for such acts is, in truth, an act of wounding religion itself.
We understand how religious texts speak of trust not merely as a moral message, but as the very foundation of any confidence placed in a person. Society respects teachers, scholars, boarding school caretakers, spiritual guides, and religious servants not merely because of their titles or positions. They are respected because they are trusted to uphold a mandate. That trust is the source of their authority. Sociologist Max Weber once reminded us that there is a form of power born not from coercion, but from trust. People follow because they believe. Precisely for this reason, the abuse of trust always leaves a deeper wound than the abuse of ordinary power.
Some time ago, I wrote that Hajj pilgrims must not be treated as commodities. That conviction remains unchanged. However, the longer I observe the various problems emerging in religious spaces, the more I realise that the issue is more fundamental. Before human beings are treated as commodities, it is trust that is traded first. The experience of organising the Hajj teaches many lessons. Rent-seeking practices, games of interest, and various forms of deviation are never born out of nowhere. It all begins when service shifts into transaction, when the mandate is seen as an opportunity rather than a responsibility. At that moment, personal interest begins to defeat the public good. This lesson applies everywhere: in Islamic boarding schools, in educational institutions, in philanthropic organisations, in religious bodies, and in public services related to worship. Wherever there is trust, there is a mandate that must be guarded.
Therefore, there must be no immunity simply because someone wears religious symbols or holds influence in society. Correcting deviations is not a form of hostility towards religion. On the contrary, it is the way to preserve the honour of religion so that it is not exploited by those who seek shelter behind it. Religion does not lose its nobility because we dare to correct deviations committed in its name. Rather, its nobility is preserved by the courage to uphold justice and care for the trust placed by the people. For when that trust is lost, what disappears is not only the authority of an institution. We lose the belief that religion remains the safest place to entrust our hopes.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/do-not-hide-behind-the-mask-of-religion-1785365430)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/opini/916263/jangan-berlindung-di-balik-topeng-agama), translated from Indonesian