DKPP Chief Disputes Claim That the 1955 Election Was Indonesia’s Best, Calling It a Myth
Dewan Kehormatan Penyelenggara Pemilu (DKPP) chair Heddy Lugito disagreed with Bawaslu member Totok Hariyono’s assertion that the best election was held in 1955. Heddy believes the claim is merely a myth.
“Earlier, Mr Totok mentioned that the best election was the 1955 election. I am sure that is a myth, based on Feith’s research. I am very sure,” Heddy said in remarks at a special talk show marking the 73rd anniversary of the General Elections Commission (KPU) at the KPU’s headquarters in Menteng, Central Jakarta, on Saturday (7 November 2026).
Heddy noted that there were few observers at the time and that reports and complaints may not have been recorded. He also said that neither Bawaslu nor the DKPP existed then.
“There was no Bawaslu and no DKPP. So, because nobody was observing or monitoring, it was considered the best,” he said.
Heddy said he was waiting for a thesis by Prof Ramlan Surbakti, chair of the KPU from 2004 to 2007, that could refute Herbert Feith’s thesis about the 1955 election being the best. He questioned whether voters had been herded or directed towards ballot boxes that year.
“So I am very sure the next election, and the one after that, will be the best. I am waiting for Prof Ramlan’s writing, and for a research review that can refute Feith’s thesis. I am very sure,” Heddy said.
“Democracy—at that time, did we look at whether people were being herded towards the ballot boxes? Were they directed towards the ballot boxes? It simply was not reported. There were also still very few journalists,” he added.
Heddy said such conditions could sometimes introduce bias into research, and that he was not convinced by Feith’s thesis.
“I think things like that can sometimes bias research. I believe there are many scholars here. I am not entirely convinced by Feith’s thesis,” he said.
Earlier, Bawaslu member Totok Hariyono had said that the best election took place in 1955, based on the literature.
Totok made the remarks while representing Bawaslu chair Rahmat Bagja at the special talk show for the KPU’s 73rd anniversary at the commission’s headquarters in Menteng, Central Jakarta, on Saturday (7 November 2026). The anniversary’s slogan was ‘Safeguarding the People’s Vote, Protecting Democracy’.
“Of course, we are very happy today, 7 November. The KPU is doing a great job with its slogan, ‘Safeguarding the People’s Vote, Protecting Democracy’. The process of choosing is no small matter, especially when its spirit comes from the 1953 Presidential Decree to oversee the 1955 election, which according to the literature was the best election,” Totok said.
Hariyono hoped the KPU’s anniversary would inspire renewed efforts to uphold the spirit of the 1955 election, which produced national leaders with statesmanlike character. He said he hoped Indonesia’s democracy would become more civilised.
“Of course, we hope the KPU’s anniversary will provide renewed inspiration and a positive spirit to uphold the ideals of the 1955 election, which produced national leaders with statesmanlike character. And we hope that, starting today, 7 November, the anniversary of the KPU, democracy in this republic will become more civilised,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dkpp-chief-disputes-claim-that-the-1955-election-was-indonesias-best-calling-it-a-myth-1794045083)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8742688/ketua-dkpp-tak-setuju-pemilu-terbaik-tahun-1955-itu-mitos), translated from Indonesian