Dissenting Opinion in Unram Student Murder Case at Nipah Beach, Defendant Sentenced to Six Years
The panel of judges at the Mataram District Court (PN) delivered a dissenting opinion in the murder case of University of Mataram (Unram) student Ni Made Vaniradya Puspa Nitra, which implicated Radiet Adiansyah, also known as Radit, as the defendant. Despite this, Radit was still sentenced to six years in prison.
The panel hearing the case consisted of Mukhlassuddin as chief judge, along with Rosihan Luthfi and Made Hermayanti Muliartha as member judges.
The two member judges were convinced that Radit was the perpetrator who took the victim’s life. They assessed that it was not another person or a robber, as Radit had previously claimed. The member judges noted that no valuable belongings of the victim or the defendant were missing, as is typical in a robbery or mugging. ‘Because that person intended to seize the property of the defendant and the victim, that person would have taken the defendant’s and victim’s belongings,’ said member judge Rosihan Luthfi on Wednesday (10/6/2026).
Furthermore, the member judges also considered the testimony of a witness who visited Radit at Bhayangkara Hospital. ‘The witness’s testimony when visiting the defendant at Bhayangkara Hospital, the defendant reportedly said, ’I’m sorry, I have taken your friend from you’,’ he stated. The member judges also considered the victim’s mother’s testimony in court. According to her, Radit had contacted the victim’s sibling via Instagram to apologise and ask to talk. ‘This indirectly proves that there was a feeling of guilt towards the victim and an admission that the defendant had committed the act,’ he mentioned.
Regarding the issue of rampant muggings or robberies at Nipah Beach, which was widely discussed on social media, Rosihan assessed that it could not be used as a basis for evidence. ‘Regarding the existence of a third party, many on social media recount that robberies or muggings often occur at Nipah Beach, but this cannot be assessed based on assumptions or social media comments whose truth cannot be accounted for,’ he said.
With these considerations, the member judges deemed the evidence presented by the defendant insufficient to prove his alibi. Therefore, the defendant’s defence or plea was rejected. ‘The evidence that has been submitted and presented by the defendant is not strong enough to prove the defendant’s alibi. Therefore, the defendant’s defence or plea must be rejected,’ he said.
Meanwhile, chief judge Mukhlassuddin stated that he disagreed with the two member judges. ‘Considering, we do not agree with the opinions of member one and two,’ said Mukhlassuddin. According to him, based on the facts of the trial, Radit was not the perpetrator who took the victim’s life. He assessed that there was a third party who must be held accountable for the incident. ‘There is a third party who must be held accountable for this incident,’ said Mukhlassuddin.
Mukhlassuddin admitted he did not find any trial facts proving Radit as the murderer. He also assessed that the public prosecutor’s construction regarding how the defendant submerged the victim’s head in the sand until the victim stopped breathing was still based on assumption. ‘We agree with the legal counsel that the defendant Radit was not proven to have committed a criminal offence as charged in the first or second alternative indictment of the public prosecutor. Therefore, the defendant must be acquitted of all charges from the public prosecutor,’ he said.
Despite the dissenting opinion, Mukhlassuddin still declared Radit proven to have committed assault causing the victim’s death. ‘Adjudicating, declaring the defendant legally and convincingly proven guilty of committing the criminal act of assault causing death, as per the second alternative indictment of the public prosecutor,’ he said. Radit was found guilty under Article 466 paragraph (3) of Law Number 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code and sentenced to six years in prison.
The panel’s verdict was lighter than the public prosecutor’s demand. Previously, the prosecutor had demanded Radit be sentenced to 13 years in prison. ‘Sentencing the defendant to imprisonment for 13 years,’ said prosecutor Sulviany during the reading of the sentencing demand at the Mataram District Court on Tuesday (2/6/2026). The prosecutor assessed that Radit was proven to have murdered his girlfriend, as stipulated in Article 458 paragraph (1) of Law Number 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code. ‘Declaring the defendant Radiet Adiansyah, also known as Radit, legally and convincingly proven guilty of committing the crime of murder, as per the first indictment of the public prosecutor,’ he stated.
It is known that the murder case occurred at Nipah Beach, Pemenang District, North Lombok, NTB, on Tuesday (26/8/2025). In this case, Radiet initially claimed that he and the victim were victims of a mugging. However, based on the results of the police investigation, Radiet was subsequently named a suspect. The case began when Radiet allegedly intended to rape the victim. The victim then fought back, leading to a scuffle between the two.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/dissenting-opinion-in-unram-student-murder-case-at-nipah-beach-defendant-sentenced-to-six-years-1781104834)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8526836/hakim-kasus-pembunuhan-mahasiswi-unram-di-pantai-nipah-beda-pendapat), translated from Indonesian