Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Digital Preaching by Santri Amid a Crisis of Expertise

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Anthropology
Digital Preaching by Santri Amid a Crisis of Expertise
Image: Republika

JAKARTA — A santri opens his phone after studying a religious text. On the screen, a 40-second video from an account with no clear teacher confidently rules on a complex question of Islamic jurisprudence, and has been watched millions of times. At the same time, a study session he attends with his kiai, complete with references and lengthy deliberation, has an audience of only a few dozen. Pesantren possess a depth of knowledge rarely found elsewhere, but that wealth can easily be outpaced. The question is no longer whether santri should be present in the digital space, but how they can participate without losing their identity.

To answer this, we can draw on three perspectives from modern communication studies. Heidi Campbell, a scholar of digital religion, shows how the internet shifts the way religious authority is formed. Authority is no longer conferred solely by institutions; it is continually negotiated before audiences who can choose, compare and challenge.

Elihu Katz and Paul Lazarsfeld, through their concept of the two-step flow of communication, remind us that messages rarely change people’s opinions directly. They are filtered and reinforced by trusted figures within the same social circles, often someone familiar and of a similar age rather than a person with the highest qualifications. Tom Nichols, author of The Death of Expertise, meanwhile, highlights the erosion of the boundary between those who have studied a subject and those who merely hold an opinion. He does not demand that the public submit to experts; he argues that experts must be worthy of trust and that the public must be willing to learn.

Our own tradition offers two guides who considered similar questions ten centuries ago. In al-Bayan wa al-Tabyin, Al-Jahiz viewed communication as the art of conveying meaning clearly in a way suited to the audience. Al-Farabi distinguished between methods of persuasion: rigorous demonstration (burhan), debate (jadal), public persuasion (khitabah) and deception masquerading as argument (safsathah). He also mapped the sciences so that each field could be recognised by its methods and limits.

From this combination, eight strategic steps can be formulated, all rooted in one principle: trust must be demonstrated, not claimed. The first is to make the sanad visible. A chain of scholarly transmission that exists only within the pesantren is invisible to a public assessing authority through a screen. Santri should therefore name their teachers and textual references, and state the limits of their knowledge.

Campbell explains that digital authority grows through recognition by a community, while Nichols argues that experts must show the path to their conclusions. The second step is to translate depth into short formats without sacrificing accuracy. Rejecting short videos means handing the arena to others.

Following Al-Jahiz’s principle, a message should be suited to the audience’s capacity. In Al-Farabi’s framework, short videos belong to the domain of khitabah, which is legitimate so long as it does not slide into safsathah. Honest, concise content should serve as a gateway to fuller study.

The third step concerns intellectual humility. Nichols’s sharpest criticism is directed at experts who speak beyond their fields. A santri specialising in Islamic jurisprudence can easily be drawn into commenting on health or politics. Our tradition has an old answer: la adri—“I do not know”—which strengthens the standing of knowledge. This also accords with Al-Farabi’s view that each discipline has its own subject and method.

The fourth step is to be a companion, not a judge. People rarely learn from someone who makes them feel foolish, and Katz and Lazarsfeld show that influence flows most strongly through personal closeness. The Qur’an itself instructs Moses and Aaron to speak gently (qawlan layyinan), even to Pharaoh.

The fifth step is to build digital tabayyun literacy: the practice of checking and verifying information. The internet creates an illusion of knowledge: people search, find fragments that fit their beliefs, and then feel they have done their research. The instruction to verify reports in verse 6 of Surah al-Hujurat offers an old answer to this new problem. Preaching should teach people how to assess answers, not merely provide them.

The sixth step is collaboration across disciplines. Expertise is narrow and deep, so when religious discussions touch on reproductive health, mental health or financial literacy, working with doctors, psychologists and economists ensures that religious messages remain grounded in evidence. Al-Farabi’s map of knowledge essentially teaches that truth is pursued through the work of multiple disciplines.

More from 26 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/digital-preaching-by-santri-amid-a-crisis-of-expertise-1792979449)
Originally published by Republika (https://opini.republika.co.id/berita/tnhmaf451/dakwah-digital-santri-di-tengah-krisis-kepakaran), translated from Indonesian
Print