Despite Apologising to Journalists, Hotman Paris Could Still Face Legal Action: Here's Why
Jakarta, VIVA – The alleged insult case against journalists involving prominent lawyer Hotman Paris Hutapea continues to unfold.
Amid the legal process now being handled by Polda Metro Jaya, legal expert Professor Henry Indraguna considers that an alleged insult against the journalistic profession can be prosecuted under the law if the elements of a criminal offence are met.
The professor at Sultan Agung Islamic University (Unissula) in Semarang affirmed that the journalistic profession is one of the key pillars of the democratic system, whose existence is guaranteed by the Press Law.
“In a democratic state based on the rule of law, the journalistic profession is one of the main pillars whose existence is guaranteed by Law Number 40 of 1999 on the Press,” said Professor Henry Indraguna on Thursday, 23 July 2026.
According to Henry, criticising a journalist’s question is part of freedom of expression. However, that is different when the statement made amounts to an insult against the profession itself.
“Criticising a journalist’s question is legitimate, but insulting the dignity of the profession cannot be justified,” he said.
Henry, who also serves on the Supervisory Board of the Legal Advocacy and Human Rights Body of the Golkar Party’s Central Executive Board, said a senior advocate should prioritise legal reasoning when expressing opinions in the public sphere, rather than personal attacks.
He added that if a statement is suspected of meeting the elements of a criminal offence, the legal process should be respected in order to provide legal certainty.
“If the statement is suspected of meeting the elements of a criminal offence, then the legal process should be respected so that there is legal certainty, whilst also serving as a lesson for all parties to maintain ethics in public communication,” he said.
According to Henry, an open apology does carry moral value. However, it does not automatically remove criminal liability if the elements of the offence have been fulfilled under applicable law.
He explained that investigators may later consider a number of provisions, including Article 315 of the Criminal Code on minor insult, Article 437 in conjunction with Article 436 of Law Number 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code, as well as provisions in Law Number 40 of 1999 on the Press, particularly Article 4 Paragraph (3) concerning the guarantee of press freedom and Article 8 on legal protection for journalists.
Nevertheless, Henry cautioned that the Press Law does not specifically regulate criminal sanctions for insults directed at journalists. The legal assessment, he said, will depend on the results of the investigation and the evidence.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/despite-apologising-to-journalists-hotman-paris-could-still-face-legal-action-heres-why-1784757036)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1915650-meski-sudah-minta-maaf-ke-wartawan-hotman-paris-dinilai-masih-bisa-diproses-hukum-ini-alasannya), translated from Indonesian