Denpasar District Court sentences lawyer Togar Situmorang to 2.5 years in prison
Denpasar (ANTARA) - The panel of judges at the Denpasar District Court, Bali, on Tuesday, sentenced lawyer Togar Situmorang to two years and six months or 2.5 years in prison in connection with a fraud case against former Putri Indonesia Fanny Lauren Cristie.
“In sentencing, the defendant Togar Situmorang is punished with two years and six months imprisonment,” said the panel of judges led by H Sayuti during the verdict hearing at the Denpasar District Court, Bali, on Tuesday.
In the presence of Public Prosecutor Ni Putu Evy Widhiarini, the defendant, and court attendees, the panel of judges stated that the defendant Togar Situmorang was legally and convincingly proven to have violated Article 492 of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code (KUHP) in conjunction with Law No. 1 of 2026 on Penalty Adjustments.
In its considerations, the panel of judges assessed that the defendant Togar Situmorang lacked good faith in carrying out his profession as a lawyer, resulting in losses to his client.
The panel of judges also dismissed the defendant’s defence, which essentially claimed he was not guilty due to immunity rights as a lawyer as regulated in the Advocate Law.
The judge’s verdict is the same as the Public Prosecutor’s demand, which sought a 2.5-year prison sentence for the defendant.
Meanwhile, Fanny Lauren Cristie said she felt grateful because the judge’s verdict matched the Public Prosecutor’s demand.
“I appreciate the panel of judges’ verdict. For me, he deceived me. I only hope there are no other victims. Before seeking a lawyer or representation, learn from my experience. So, it’s better to seek advice beforehand,” she said.
According to the prosecutor’s indictment, the case stemmed from a legal dispute between Fanny and Italian citizen Luca Simioni regarding the Double View Mansions property project in the Pererenan area, Badung.
In that matter, the defendant Togar Situmorang offered legal services to Fanny at a fee of Rp550 million. The first meeting between them took place on 7 August 2022 at Togar’s office on Jalan Gatot Subroto Timur, Denpasar. Four days later, on 11 August 2022, Fanny agreed to the offer and handed over a down payment of Rp300 million in cash.
However, the prosecutor revealed that the payment was not accompanied by an official receipt. Subsequently, Fanny made further transfers totalling Rp550 million to an account in the name of Ellen Mulyawati, who is said to be a close associate of the defendant.
After receiving the payment, Togar allegedly began promising legally implausible things. He is said to have convinced Fanny that to make Luca Simioni a suspect at Bareskrim Polri, an additional “mahar” of Rp1 billion was needed.
The indictment states that this occurred on 26 August 2022, when Fanny, Togar, Valerio Tocci, and I Ketut Gede Swastika visited Bareskrim Polri to report Simioni. After filing the report, they gathered at a restaurant in the Melawai area, Jakarta.
There, the defendant said to his client, “This is already for the report, so everyone will be examined later, but like this Fan, there’s something you need to prepare to make Luca Simioni a suspect.”
Fanny Lauren Christie replied, “What needs to be prepared, bang,” and the defendant said, “Your money, Fan.” Witness Christie asked again, “How much, bang,” and the defendant said, “Around Rp1,000,000,000.”
“Hah, that much, bang,” said Fanny.
The defendant replied, “If you can prepare that money, Luca Simioni will definitely become a suspect.”
Still on the same occasion, when asked about guarantees, the defendant said, “The guarantee is that he will definitely become a suspect and this person must be deported; when I get to Bali, I’ll let you know about Immigration.”
According to the prosecutor, that statement was entirely untrue. The process of designating a suspect does not require Rp1 billion, and Bareskrim investigators never requested such funds.
“The defendant said that only to mislead witness Fanny Lauren Christie’s understanding so that she would be motivated to hand over money to the defendant,” the prosecutor explained.
The defendant promised deportation of Luca Simioni if Fanny prepared Rp500 million. Fanny believed the promise and sent the money in two transfers of Rp250 million each.
However, the officials mentioned had no relationship or agreement whatsoever with the defendant. In January 2023, the defendant again employed deception. Via WhatsApp message, he wrote: “Kapolres Badung have final agree and instruction to him make gelar and close this case,” meaning “The Badung Police Chief has finally agreed and instructed his team to hold a case review and terminate this case.”
When Fanny inquired about case developments on 22 February 2023, the defendant replied, “After Tmmr afternoon,” then via phone mentioned that to obtain an SP3 letter, Rp200 million was needed.
“In fact, issuing a notice of termination of investigation does not require that amount of money, and the Badung Police Chief never requested such funds,” said the prosecutor.
As a result of that persuasion, the victim again transferred Rp200 million to the account in the name of Ellen Mulyawati.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denpasar-district-court-sentences-lawyer-togar-situmorang-to-2-5-years-in-prison-1777377145)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5545925/pn-denpasar-vonis-advokat-togar-situmorang-25-tahun-penjara), translated from Indonesian