Denny Rebukes Gibran: Supreme Court Ruling Is Final, with No Further Legal Recourse
Constitutional law expert Denny Indrayana has weighed in on Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming’s plan to pursue further legal action over controversy surrounding his high-school diploma during the 2024 presidential election.
Denny stressed that the Supreme Court (MA) ruling is final and legally binding. The Constitutional Court (MK) ruling before it was likewise final and binding.
“So, if he wants to take legal action, as Coordinating Minister Yusril said, there is no longer any available. The MK ruling is final and binding. The MA ruling is final and legally binding; there can be no further legal action,” Denny said at a press conference on Tuesday (10 November).
Denny therefore expressed regret over Gibran’s statement, which appeared to follow President Prabowo Subianto’s instruction to pursue a case at the State Administrative Court (PTUN). He said the statement amounted to defiance of the two courts’ rulings, by the MK and MA.
“That stance shows—imagine, a vice-president defying and failing to respect the rulings of two courts,” Denny said.
In Denny’s view, after the MK and MA decisions, Gibran should have complied and announced his resignation. He said Gibran was wrong to say he would fight and challenge the rulings in the dispute over his diploma.
Moreover, the MA’s legal reasoning explicitly stated that Gibran’s certificate of educational equivalency could no longer serve as a basis. That reasoning was consistent with the MK’s earlier decision.
“The reasoning clearly says this is to save our democracy. There were violations that were structured, systematic and planned,” he said.
Gibran had previously said he would fight the matter at the PTUN over the controversy surrounding his high-school diploma equivalency certificate. He said he would coordinate with the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education to seek a judicial review of the MA ruling, which declared the certificate invalid and void.
“One of his [President Prabowo’s] suggestions was that I continue to fight at the PTUN by presenting all the documents from primary school through to my bachelor’s degree, and also coordinate with the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education to seek a judicial review at the MA. That’s all,” he said yesterday.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denny-rebukes-gibran-supreme-court-ruling-is-final-with-no-further-legal-recourse-1794361924)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261111080026-20-1425696/denny-sentil-gibran-putusan-ma-inkrah-tak-ada-upaya-hukum-lain), translated from Indonesian