Denny JA: State Losses Should Not Be the Core Element of Corruption Offences
Jakarta (VIVA) – State losses should no longer be a core element of corruption offences. The law must clearly distinguish between losses resulting from reasonable business risks and losses arising from crime.
This view was expressed by Denny JA, President Commissioner and Independent Commissioner of Pertamina Hulu Energi (PHE), in an essay entitled “Why Should State Losses No Longer Be a Core Element of Corruption Offences? Lessons from the 10 Cleanest Countries”, published on Denny JA’s World Facebook page.
“Corruption can occur without state losses, and state losses can occur without corruption,” Denny JA wrote.
He said that an official who accepts a bribe has committed corruption even if the project awarded to them benefits the state. Conversely, directors of a state-owned enterprise (SOE) who make investment decisions professionally do not automatically commit corruption if their investment incurs a loss.
“A loss is an economic consequence. Corruption is a betrayal of trust,” he stressed.
Lessons from the cleanest countries
Denny JA referred to the 2025 Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI), published by Transparency International on 10 February 2026.
In the index, Denmark scored 89, Finland 88, Singapore 84, New Zealand and Norway 81, Sweden and Switzerland 80, Luxembourg and the Netherlands 78, and Germany and Iceland 77.
These 11 countries occupy the top 10 positions because of a tie in the rankings.
According to Denny JA, anti-bribery laws in these countries focus on corrupt acts rather than requiring the loss of public money.
However, he stressed, this does not mean that all these countries exclude economic loss from every criminal offence.
“The more honest lesson is this: loss is no substitute for proving the prohibited conduct and the elements of fault required by law,” he wrote.
This principle is also reflected in the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC), whose Article 3(2) states that offences under the convention generally do not have to result in damage to state property.
Meanwhile, Indonesia scored 34 in the 2025 CPI and ranked 109th out of 182 countries.
Business risks should not be criminalised
Denny JA warned of a chilling effect, in which company leaders become afraid to make productive decisions because business failures could expose them to criminal proceedings.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denny-ja-state-losses-should-not-be-the-core-element-of-corruption-offences-1792846226)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1938325-denny-ja-kerugian-negara-jangan-jadi-inti-delik-korupsi), translated from Indonesian