Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Denny Indrayana Warns Gibran He Is Wrong to Challenge the Ruling at the Administrative Court: He Should Resign

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Denny Indrayana Warns Gibran He Is Wrong to Challenge the Ruling at the Administrative Court: He Should Resign
Image: detikcom

Former Deputy Law Minister Denny Indrayana says Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka would be wrong to take the dispute over his diploma to the State Administrative Court (PTUN). Denny described Gibran’s plan as a bad example, arguing that it defies rulings by the Constitutional Court (MK) and Supreme Court (MA).

“What Mr Gibran is doing is a very poor example from the perspective of the Constitution and the ethics of governing a country. Once there is a Constitutional Court ruling that is final and binding, and a Supreme Court ruling that is legally final and binding, Mr Gibran should respect and comply with them, and then declare that he is stepping down,” Denny said at a press conference broadcast on his YouTube channel on Tuesday (10 November 2026).

Denny urged Gibran to resign instead of pursuing further legal action. He said Gibran should announce his intention publicly.

“I believe he should make clear his intention to resign — to leave the office of Vice-President, as provided for in Article 8 of the 1945 Constitution. Mr Gibran should state that intention publicly,” he said.

Denny also referred to a meeting between Gibran and President Prabowo Subianto. He said he was sure Prabowo would not reject Gibran if he intended to resign.

“If Mr Gibran says, ‘I want to go to the State Administrative Court’, perhaps Mr Prabowo would say, ‘Yes, go ahead’. But that does not mean his intention to resign has been rejected. We must not allow this to be manipulated: the President’s courtesy should not be interpreted as permission not to resign or as a rejection of his resignation,” he said.

Denny called on Gibran to take a firm position. He said no further legal action could be taken over the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court rulings concerning Gibran’s education documents.

“We are waiting for Mr Gibran to show real resolve and take the position we have been waiting for: resigning as Vice-President because there have already been rulings by the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court. This ruling is, so to speak, in the seventh heaven, with no heaven above it. As Coordinating Minister Yusril said, there is no further legal recourse,” Denny said.

Denny went on to say that Gibran’s plans to bring the matter to the State Administrative Court and seek a judicial review (PK) of the Supreme Court ruling were misguided.

“Moreover, choosing to fight — to challenge the ruling — is entirely wrong. We have now received a copy of the Supreme Court ruling concerning Gibran’s education-equivalency certificate. The certificate was declared void, and the ministry was ordered to revoke it,” he said.

On the proposed judicial review, Denny said Gibran was not entitled to seek one because he had no legal standing in the case.

“Mr Gibran has no legal standing because he was not a party to the case. Remember, the claimant was Mr Subhan Pala and the defendant was the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education, so Mr Gibran cannot seek a judicial review. I understand from Coordinating Minister Yusril’s statement that the ministry will revoke the document challenged in the case; we will wait and see,” Denny said.

Denny criticised Gibran’s understanding of the law, saying a public official — particularly a vice-president — should have a thorough grasp of law and the Constitution.

“Such matters should be understood by a vice-president if he understands law and the Constitution. Why use words such as ‘fight’ or ‘challenge’ through the State Administrative Court, and why seek a judicial review? This further confirms that Mr Gibran is not fit to be Vice-President and lacks the understanding and capacity to recognise that going to the State Administrative Court is the wrong course, and that taking the matter to the Supreme Court through a judicial review is also wrong,” he added.

Gibran earlier spoke about his meeting with Prabowo. He said he did not want the current developments to become a prolonged political controversy, but intended to challenge the matter at the State Administrative Court.

“I respect all the public’s aspirations, criticism and advice regarding the current developments. I do not want them to become a prolonged political controversy,” Gibran said at the Vice-Presidential Palace in Central Jakarta on Tuesday (10 November).

More from 11 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denny-indrayana-warns-gibran-he-is-wrong-to-challenge-the-ruling-at-the-administrative-court-he-should-resign-1794358268)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8747518/denny-indrayana-ingatkan-gibran-keliru-melawan-ke-ptun-harusnya-mundur), translated from Indonesian
Print