Denny Indrayana: Has the Constitutional Court Given a Clue on Gibran’s Impeachment? Will Parliament Act?
Former Deputy Law and Human Rights Minister Denny Indrayana hopes the House of Representatives (DPR RI) will follow up on the Constitutional Court’s (MK) ruling concerning the absence of a senior secondary school or equivalent certificate for Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka. Denny said the court had left further steps, including impeachment, to other institutions.
Denny said he had not given up hope that Gibran would be disqualified from the vice-presidency. However, he questioned why the DPR had yet to take any action.
“Hope should not be lost; of course there is hope. That is optimism. But whether it can be realised is another matter. So where is the concrete movement in the DPR so far?” Denny said when contacted on Thursday (8 October 2026).
Denny stressed that the MK had made it clear that it had not found a certificate showing Gibran met the educational requirement for standing in the 2024 election. He also said the court had invited other institutions to pursue the facts it had set out.
“Just look at what the MK said, plainly and clearly. How can anyone dispute it? The language is clear: there is no senior secondary school certificate, as required by the Election Law. That is clear. How can people twist it around? Those are the words of the Constitutional Court. And in fact, the MK said, ‘Other institutions may take this further’, didn’t it?” he said.
Denny said the MK had given a clue about an impeachment process. He added, however, that the authority did not lie with the court, but with another institution: the DPR.
“If there had been no finding, why would it give a clue about an impeachment process? The MK clearly said, ‘This is the authority of another institution’ — meaning impeachment. Why did the MK give that clue? Because the person concerned did not meet the requirements to be a vice-presidential candidate,” he said.
“Of course I hope the DPR will act. The question is, will the DPR get moving or not?” he added.
Denny also said he believed there were only two options for Gibran: resign or be removed.
“There are really only two possible next steps: resign or be removed. For Gibran to resign, he needs only two things: a sense of shame and a sense of propriety. There are only two options, resign or be removed. The requirements are two as well: knowing one’s place and feeling shame. Unless he has neither, there is no hope,” he said.
The MK rejected a petition in an election-dispute case concerning the educational qualifications Gibran met when registering for the 2024 presidential election. However, the court said it had found no evidence of a senior secondary school-equivalent certificate for Gibran.
MK Justice Arsul Sani explained that the certificate of attendance had been used as the basis for issuing a letter stating that Gibran had completed education equivalent to senior secondary school overseas. He said there was no document showing that Gibran had completed senior secondary education abroad.
“Meanwhile, the certificate of attendance and other documents used as the basis for issuing Letter No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019 do not attest to the successful completion of any particular level of education; they only confirm attendance at classes,” Arsul said during the ruling at the MK building in Jakarta on Tuesday (6 October).
However, the MK said it could not disqualify Gibran.
“The Court cannot annul or disqualify Gibran Rakabuming Raka from his position as Vice-President, as requested in the applicants’ petition,” MK Justice Adies Kadir said.
The MK said it had no authority to assess whether presidential and vice-presidential candidates met the requirements, even though it had found that Gibran had no certificate from his studies abroad. Adies said another institution had jurisdiction over the matter.
“Regarding the fact established by the Court that there was no overseas certificate, diploma or other qualification serving as the basis for recognising education equivalent to at least completion of senior secondary school, madrasah aliyah, vocational secondary school, vocational madrasah or another equivalent school, the matter substantively falls within the remit of the institution authorised to assess the validity of, and compliance with, the requirements for presidential and vice-presidential candidates under the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia,” Adies said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denny-indrayana-has-the-constitutional-court-given-a-clue-on-gibrans-impeachment-will-parliament-act-1791507180)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8698882/denny-indrayana-mk-beri-clue-pemakzulan-gibran-dpr-gas-nggak), translated from Indonesian