Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Denny Indrayana: Gibran No Longer Meets the Requirements to Serve as Vice-President

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Denny Indrayana: Gibran No Longer Meets the Requirements to Serve as Vice-President
Image: CNN Indonesia

Former Deputy Minister of Law and Human Rights Denny Indrayana said a Supreme Court ruling concerning Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high-school equivalency certificate reinforced a Constitutional Court ruling on the educational requirements for vice-presidential candidates.

Denny said the two rulings showed that Gibran no longer met the education requirements for holding the vice-presidency.

“Through the Constitutional Court ruling, as confirmed and reinforced by the Supreme Court, Gibran no longer meets the requirements to serve as Vice-President, particularly the education requirement in this case,” Denny told reporters on Tuesday (3 November).

Denny argued that the matter should be followed up through the impeachment process. He said this route was necessary because Gibran had already been inaugurated and was serving as Vice-President.

“This is important in affirming that the impeachment process should proceed. Why impeachment after this? Because following the Constitutional Court ruling, a clearer line was drawn: after inauguration, if problems arise involving the President or Vice-President, the remedy is removal from office through impeachment, not disqualification, according to the Constitutional Court,” he said.

Denny explained that the applicable legal mechanism would be different if the issue had arisen before inauguration. In that case, he said, disqualification could still be possible under election law.

“Before inauguration, it could still fall under election law, and disqualification could still be possible,” he added.

The Supreme Court had earlier granted an appeal filed by a member of the public, HM Subhan, concerning Gibran’s overseas high-school equivalency certificate. In its ruling, the court declared the certificate invalid and void by law.

“Appeal granted. The judex facti decision is set aside. The court rules on the merits: the claimant’s case is granted in full,” the Supreme Court said in decision No. 742 K/TUN/2026, according to its official website on Friday (30 October).

The appeal followed the rejection of Subhan’s lawsuit against the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education at the Jakarta State Administrative Court.

Subhan then appealed, but the State Administrative High Court upheld the Jakarta court’s decision. The case proceeded to the Supreme Court, which ultimately granted the claim.

The document at the centre of the case was Certificate No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019. It certified the equivalence of Gibran’s overseas high-school education and was used as one of the requirements for his candidacy for vice-president in the 2024 election.

In an earlier ruling, the Constitutional Court said it had found no evidence of Gibran’s overseas high-school diploma on which the equivalency certificate had been based.

Gibran’s lawyer, Muhammad Rullyandi, said the Supreme Court ruling did not affect his client’s position as Vice-President.

He argued that the ruling could not be fully implemented because the legal circumstances had changed before it was issued.

“I believe the Supreme Court ruling granting the application to revoke the validity of Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high-school equivalency certificate, which was an administrative requirement for his vice-presidential candidacy in the 2024 election, does not affect Gibran’s position as Vice-President,” Rullyandi said, as quoted by detikcom on Saturday (31 October).

“The reason is that the Supreme Court ruling cannot be fully executed because a prior legal situation has intervened,” he added.

Rullyandi said the Supreme Court issued its ruling after all stages of the 2024 presidential election had concluded and Gibran had officially been inaugurated as Vice-President. He therefore argued that the ruling could not be applied retrospectively.

“The Supreme Court ruling meets the criteria under the State Administrative Court framework, with reference to Article 117(1) of Law No. 5 of 1986, which in essence provides that a ruling that cannot be properly implemented cannot be executed because a prior legal situation has arisen,” he said.

Rullyandi also said the equivalency certificate had been used to meet administrative requirements during the 2024 election process, which has now concluded. He maintained that, although the Supreme Court ruling is legally binding, it cannot be applied.

More from 3 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denny-indrayana-gibran-no-longer-meets-the-requirements-to-serve-as-vice-president-1793688807)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261103123351-20-1422719/denny-indrayana-gibran-tak-lagi-memenuhi-syarat-sebagai-wapres), translated from Indonesian
Print