Denny Indrayana Considers Facing Gibran in Administrative Court
Senior lawyer Denny Indrayana is considering returning to court and reversing his decision to withdraw a lawsuit at the Administrative Court (PTUN) concerning the high-school education-equivalency certificate issued by the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education for Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka during the 2024 presidential election.
Indrayana made the statement in response to Gibran’s plan to disclose details of his education documents.
Indrayana suspects Gibran intends to mount a legal challenge through a case brought by Mercy Sihombing at the Administrative Court. Indrayana, who was one of the lawyers representing her, previously withdrew the case following a Constitutional Court ruling, which was reinforced by a Supreme Court appeal decision.
“So, when he says he will take steps to establish the facts in the Administrative Court, I understand this to refer to the case filed by Ms Mercy Sihombing, in which Herianto, several colleagues and I are her lawyers. That is not only an act of defiance, but also a mistake,” Indrayana said at a press conference in Jakarta on Tuesday (10 November).
“We will discuss our next steps with the client. If necessary, we will have to appear at the hearing,” he added.
Indrayana is also taking into account a statement by Coordinating Minister for Law, Human Rights, Immigration and Corrections Yusril Ihza Mahendra, who said the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education would implement the Supreme Court ruling by revoking Gibran’s high-school equivalency certificate.
He said his team would also coordinate with Supreme Court appellant Subhan Palal to write to the ministry and request that the ruling be implemented promptly.
“We will coordinate with one of the appellants, Mr Subhan Palal, as the plaintiff, to follow up by writing to the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education and asking it to revoke the certificate as soon as possible,” he said.
Citing Article 7, paragraph 2 of Law No. 30/2014 on Government Administration, Indrayana said the government is obliged to implement decisions that have become legally binding. He therefore considers Gibran’s plan to challenge the matter at the Administrative Court and seek a judicial review to be mistaken.
“From every perspective of administrative and constitutional law, taking up the fight—as the Vice-President put it—through Ms Mercy’s case at the Administrative Court is not only disrespectful to the Constitution, but also wrong in strategy and concept,” he said.
Gibran had earlier said he would fight the matter at the Administrative Court over the controversy surrounding his high-school certificate. He said he would coordinate with the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education to seek a judicial review of the Supreme Court ruling, which declared the equivalency certificate invalid and void.
“One of the President’s suggestions was that I continue to fight at the Administrative Court by presenting all my documents, from primary school through to my bachelor’s degree, and coordinate with the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education to seek a judicial review at the Supreme Court. That’s all,” he said yesterday.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denny-indrayana-considers-facing-gibran-in-administrative-court-1794365490)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261111091202-12-1425720/denny-indrayana-buka-opsi-ladeni-gibran-fight-di-ptun), translated from Indonesian