Denny Indrayana and Others Set Out Five Steps After Gibran Certificate Ruling
Former Deputy Minister of Law and Human Rights Denny Indrayana says he will take five further steps following a Supreme Court ruling that a certificate recognising Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high-school education is invalid. One of the steps is to press for political proceedings to impeach him.
“First, political proceedings: urging that Gibran be dismissed — more precisely, removed from office — through impeachment,” Denny said at a press conference in Jakarta on Monday (2 November 2026).
Denny said failure to initiate impeachment would amount to a betrayal of the Constitution, particularly given a Constitutional Court ruling that, he said, was consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision.
“If no effort is made to impeach him, we are witnessing with our own eyes a betrayal of the principles of the rule of law,” he said.
“If the House of Representatives, or parliament, takes no action, that also means allowing defiance of the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court rulings,” he added.
Denny said impeachment would not necessarily have to apply to both the president and vice-president once they had taken office. The process, he said, could be directed at Gibran alone.
“The ‘one package’ applies in the context of candidate pairs. That is under the election regime: a presidential candidate and a vice-presidential candidate are called a candidate pair, and that pair is one package,” he said.
Denny also referred to ethical proceedings concerning the General Elections Commission (KPU), the election organiser, noting that a complaint had been filed with the Elections Organiser Ethics Council (DKPP). He also cited criminal and administrative proceedings among the further steps being pursued.
“Third, criminal proceedings, which elements of civil society are pursuing. Fourth, administrative court proceedings, which we are urging the Supreme Court to continue to respect, including our response to Ms Mercy’s lawsuit. That is an administrative court case. Finally, administrative proceedings,” he said.
In addition to those five avenues, Denny said he had written to the relevant ministry to request that Gibran’s academic transcript be disclosed in full. He said the transcript should be made public to establish the facts.
“For the record, we have written to the ministry to request, in particular, the transcript. This keeps being concealed,” he said.
Denny said he would also write to the Ombudsman over alleged maladministration by the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education (Kemendikdasmen).
“This week, we will write to the Ombudsman. This is an administrative matter. Why? Because this is maladministration. Maladministration is not only a failure to issue a certificate, but also a failure to provide the basis for issuing it; that too is an administrative matter,” he said.
“We sent a letter to Kemendikdasmen almost two weeks ago and copied it to the Ombudsman. Now we will formally write to the Ombudsman to emphasise that Kemendikdasmen has committed an administrative violation — maladministration,” he added.
Subhan, who brought the case concerning Gibran’s certificate to the Supreme Court, said he planned to take further action if the ruling was not implemented.
“As the plaintiff, I want to invoke Article 8(2) directly. If it is not implemented within 60 days, I have already begun counting the days until I drive the vice-president out of the Palace,” Subhan said.
The Supreme Court ruling
The Supreme Court granted an appeal by Subhan concerning the certificate recognising Gibran’s high-school education from overseas. The court declared the certificate invalid and void by law.
“Appeal granted. The judex facti ruling is set aside. The court rules on the merits: the plaintiff’s claim is granted in full,” the Supreme Court said in decision No. 742 K/TUN/2026, as quoted on its official website on Friday (30 October).
Subhan’s appeal followed his lawsuit at the Jakarta State Administrative Court, case No. 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT, against Kemendikdasmen. The court initially rejected the lawsuit. Subhan appealed, but the High Administrative Court upheld the Jakarta court’s ruling. He then appealed to the Supreme Court, which granted his claim.
Certificate No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019 recognises Gibran’s overseas high-school education and was used when he registered as a vice-presidential candidate in 2024. In its ruling, the Constitutional Court said it had found no evidence of Gibran’s overseas high-school diploma being used as the basis for issuing the equivalency certificate.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/denny-indrayana-and-others-set-out-five-steps-after-gibran-certificate-ruling-1793634737)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8735512/ini-5-langkah-bakal-diambil-denny-indrayana-dkk-usai-putusan-suket-gibran), translated from Indonesian