Democrat’s Jansen: Gibran Must Resign as Vice-President or Be Removed
Democrat Party Deputy Secretary-General Jansen Sitindaon said Gibran Rakabuming Raka no longer meets the requirements to serve as vice-president.
His statement followed a Supreme Court ruling that the certificate used by Gibran as a qualification for his candidacy in the 2024 presidential election was invalid.
Jansen said the court’s ruling was explicit and clear, leaving no need for further interpretation. He said it affected Gibran’s legitimacy as vice-president.
“Because the Supreme Court ruling has declared the certificate dated 6 August 2019 invalid and void by operation of law — and, further, in point three, ordered the judge to have it destroyed — I have no choice but to say that, legally, Mr Gibran’s legitimacy as vice-president no longer meets the requirements, in line with the wording of Article 7A of the Constitution,” Jansen said, as quoted from his social media account on Sunday (1 November).
Jansen contrasted the Supreme Court ruling with an earlier Constitutional Court decision. In his view, the Constitutional Court’s ruling left room for interpretation, whereas the Supreme Court’s order was more definitive.
“Unlike the Supreme Court ruling, whose order states very firmly, plainly and clearly — and needs no further interpretation — that [the certificate is] ‘invalid, void by operation of law, to be taken from whoever possesses it and destroyed’,” he said.
On that basis, Jansen said there were now two options: Gibran could resign, or the House of Representatives and the People’s Consultative Assembly could take political action to impeach him.
“Since he is no longer legitimate and does not meet the requirements to be vice-president, in my view there are only two options: Mr Gibran resigns honourably as vice-president, or the House, through the People’s Consultative Assembly, ‘removes’ him by invoking Article 7A of the Constitution,” he said.
Jansen said the House and the Assembly would have a role in following up the ruling if Gibran did not resign voluntarily.
“In criminal cases, the prosecutor executes the ruling; in civil cases, it is the bailiff. In this case, because it concerns a state office, if the person does not resign voluntarily, the House, through the Assembly, is the enforcer. Otherwise, the ruling will simply remain on paper,” he said.
However, Jansen said it remained to be seen whether the matter would lead to political action in the House and the Assembly. He said decisions on possible enforcement lay with senior political figures and party elites.
“Whether this case proceeds to political ‘enforcement’ by the House through the Assembly remains to be seen. This is not yet at my level to discuss; it is a matter for the ‘gods’ whose place is in the ‘heavens’. Those of us still on the ‘ground’ can only offer a legal opinion,” he said.
The Supreme Court had earlier granted an appeal in a lawsuit challenging the validity of Gibran’s certificate of equivalency for senior secondary school.
In its ruling, the court declared invalid the certificate of equivalency that Gibran used to meet the requirements for his candidacy in the 2024 presidential election.
Gibran’s lawyer, Muhammad Rullyandi, said the Supreme Court ruling did not affect his client’s position as vice-president.
He argued that the ruling could not be fully enforced because the legal circumstances had changed before it was issued.
“I believe the Supreme Court ruling granting the application to annul the validity of Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s certificate of equivalency for senior secondary education, which was an administrative requirement for his vice-presidential candidacy in the 2024 election, does not affect Gibran’s position as vice-president,” Rullyandi said, as quoted by detikcom on Saturday (31 October).
“The reason is that the Supreme Court ruling cannot be fully enforced because of the legal circumstances that existed beforehand,” he added.
Rullyandi explained that the Supreme Court issued its ruling after all stages of the 2024 presidential election had concluded and Gibran had officially been inaugurated as vice-president. He therefore said the decision could not be applied retroactively.
“The Supreme Court ruling meets the criteria under the State Administrative Court framework, with reference to Article 117(1) of Law No. 5/1986, which in essence provides that an imperfect ruling cannot be enforced because a prior legal situation has already arisen,” he said.
Rullyandi said the certificate of educational equivalency had been used to meet administrative candidacy requirements during the 2024 election, which has now concluded. He said that although the Supreme Court ruling was legally binding, it could not be applied.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/democrats-jansen-gibran-must-resign-as-vice-president-or-be-removed-1793541051)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261101184849-32-1422083/jansen-demokrat-pilihannya-mas-gibran-mundur-wapres-atau-dimundurkan), translated from Indonesian