Democrats and PSI Trade Barbs Over Gibran’s Diploma Controversy, AHY Drawn In
The controversy over Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high-school diploma has prompted an exchange of statements between politicians from the Democratic Party and the Indonesian Solidarity Party (PSI). Democratic Party chairman Agus Harimurti Yudhoyono (AHY) was also drawn into the debate.
According to detikNews, Democratic Party deputy secretary-general Jansen Sitindaon said Gibran no longer met the requirements to serve as vice-president following the Supreme Court ruling. Jansen said Gibran now had two options: resign as vice-president or be impeached by the House of Representatives and the People’s Consultative Assembly.
The debate followed a Supreme Court ruling that found invalid a certificate recognising Gibran’s overseas high-school education as equivalent to Indonesian schooling. Jansen had first criticised a Constitutional Court ruling on a challenge related to the 2024 election results and Gibran’s high-school diploma, which he said was inconclusive.
The Constitutional Court ruling said that Gibran’s high-school diploma had not been found, or could not be found. Jansen said the latest Supreme Court ruling was different.
“Unlike the Supreme Court ruling, whose operative order is very firm, clear and explicit, and needs no further interpretation, it states: ‘invalid, void by law, to be withdrawn from whoever holds it and destroyed’,” Jansen wrote on his social media account on Sunday (1 November).
In response to the Supreme Court’s declaration that the certificate was invalid and void by law, and its order that it be destroyed, Jansen argued that Gibran no longer had a legitimate basis to serve as vice-president.
“If we follow the wording of the Supreme Court’s operative order literally, as the legal source, then Mas Gibran’s current status as vice-president is no longer valid and is void by law, in line with the status of the certificate he used, which the Supreme Court has now ordered to be destroyed,” he said.
“Since he is no longer validly qualified to serve as vice-president, in my view there are now only two options: Mas Gibran resigns honourably, or the House of Representatives and, in turn, the People’s Consultative Assembly ‘remove’ him by invoking Article 7A of the 1945 Constitution,” he added.
Jansen then discussed the possibility that the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court rulings could lead to political action in the legislature. He said any such move by the House and the People’s Consultative Assembly would be in the hands of senior political figures and elites.
“This is now a matter for the ‘gods’, whose station is in the heavens. Those of us still on the ground can only offer legal opinions,” Jansen said.
Bestari of PSI accuses AHY of seeking the vice-presidency
Jansen’s remarks drew a response from PSI central board member Bestari Barus, who said he was surprised that the Democrats had reacted so quickly to the ruling.
Bestari first questioned the Supreme Court decision concerning Gibran’s high-school equivalency certificate, asking whether its written copy had been made public.
“First, I would ask whether he has seen or directly accessed the written copy of the Supreme Court ruling. In other words, there has been nothing official about the Supreme Court’s position or ruling published to the public. So what is he presenting this as, in what capacity, and what is the basis for his information?” Bestari said when contacted on Monday (2 November).
Bestari said that if the written ruling concerning Gibran had not been made public, it should not yet be the subject of comment. He suspected the Democrats were reacting hastily because they wanted AHY to become vice-president.
“If there is indeed no copy of the ruling that has been submitted or recorded in the State Gazette, then what Jansen has said is something that should only be discussed within the Democratic Party, not publicised,” Bestari said.
“Why rush to respond? Do you want AHY to become vice-president?” he added.
Bestari said Jansen’s remarks risked stirring public and political turmoil. He urged Jansen to study the Supreme Court ruling more carefully first.
“Don’t become a trigger for turmoil in political discourse and society. Jansen, and perhaps AHY, should learn more about what was decided. If you haven’t even read it, how can you comment on the written ruling?” he said.
Bestari called on all parties to wait for the Supreme Court’s written ruling on Gibran to be released publicly. Once it had been published, he said, it could be examined together.
“As the party that was among the first to support and strengthen the Prabowo-Gibran camp, PSI has a somewhat different view from supporters of Prabowo-Gibran who came along at the very end,” Bestari said.
“We should wait for the Supreme Court’s written ruling. Once it is officially released, we can read and examine together what actually underlies the decision,” he added.
Jansen tells PSI not to drag AHY into the dispute
Jansen then responded to Bestari’s remarks, rejecting the suggestion that AHY wanted to become vice-president in connection with the controversy over Gibran’s high-school equivalency certificate.
“I think it is a stretch for Bang Bestari Barus to link my comments about the Supreme Court ruling to Mas AHY’s supposed desire to become vice-president. Mas AHY should not be dragged into this matter,” Jansen said when contacted on Monday (2 November).
Jansen said legal and constitutional issues should not be conflated with political speculation. He said the appointment of a vice-president was entirely within the authority of President Prabowo Subianto.
“Legal and constitutional matters should not be mixed up with speculation about political interests or who will become vice-president,” Jansen said.
“Furthermore, if such an appointment were to take place, under our Constitution it would be entirely the President’s prerogative; even the supporting parties would not need to be involved. This differs from filling a vacant regional leadership post,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/democrats-and-psi-trade-barbs-over-gibrans-diploma-controversy-ahy-drawn-in-1793674236)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/berita/d-8735741/saling-balas-demokrat-vs-psi-soal-polemik-ijazah-gibran-ahy-kena-senggol), translated from Indonesian