Democratic Party Proposes 'National Constituency' for DPR Elections; PDIP Warns Against Sacrificing the System
The Democratic Party (PD) has proposed the concept of a ‘National Constituency’ or national pool for the election of members of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI), alongside discussions regarding the parliamentary threshold. The Chairperson of the PDI-P Central Executive Board, Said Abdullah, warned that while the proposal aims to minimise wasted votes, it must not sacrifice the established electoral system.
“In every election, many votes are indeed lost, but we must not sacrifice the system. If the system is sacrificed and remaining votes are suddenly collected at a national level, what system are we actually using?” Said stated at the parliamentary complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Monday (21/9/2026).
Said argued that it is preferable for legislative elections to be finalised within their respective constituencies. He maintains that the Sainte-Laguë method, which serves as the reference for converting party votes into parliamentary seats, should remain in effect.
“Would it not be better, as has been the case, for the process to conclude at the constituency level? Or at the very least, if there is an idea for a ‘stembus accord’ (merging remaining votes) at the provincial level, that would essentially be a reversal of our current direction,” Said remarked. He added that the calculation method should follow the 1; 3; 5 pattern or a modification such as 1; 1.5; 3; 5, noting that PDI-P supports the 1; 1.5; 3; 5 model.
Previously, the Deputy Chairman of the Democratic Party, Dede Yusuf, responded to NasDem Party Chairman Surya Paloh’s consistent proposal to set the parliamentary threshold at 7%. The Democrats highlighted that tens of millions of votes were rendered invalid under the 4% threshold applied in the previous election.
“The Democratic Party is currently reviewing this, and it is not about the percentage. It is about how many people’s votes will be wasted if the concept relies solely on a percentage-based threshold. During the last election, a 4% threshold resulted in 17 million wasted votes. In 2009, a 2.5% threshold led to 19 million wasted votes,” Dede said on Sunday (20/9).
Dede explained that the Democratic Party is proposing a ‘National Constituency’ or national pool concept for DPR elections. He emphasised that the surplus votes from parties that pass the threshold could be pooled to determine additional seats in the DPR.
Dede also referenced the ‘stembus accord’ model used in the 1999 Election, expressing hope that studying this concept could reduce the number of wasted votes. “That is why the Democrats have proposed the ‘National Constituency’ concept from the start. The surplus votes from parties that pass the threshold would be converted into a national constituency so that no votes are wasted. The ‘stembus accord’ model was used previously,” he said.
Nevertheless, Dede Yusuf noted that the proposal is still being studied by the party, pointing out that similar systems are utilised in New Zealand and Germany.
“It is still being processed. This system exists in New Zealand and Germany as well,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/democratic-party-proposes-national-constituency-for-dpr-elections-pdip-warns-against-sacrificing-the-system-1789985167)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8672619/pd-usul-ada-dapil-nasional-di-pemilu-dpr-pdip-jangan-korbankan-sistem), translated from Indonesian