Democracy without education: Quo vadis?
Democracy without education: Quo vadis?
Nirwan Idrus, Executive Director, Indonesian Institute for
Management Development (IPMI), Jakarta
How do we move forward to sort these problems out rather than
becoming embroiled in more rhetoric and useless arguments?
Here is a potential proposal, accepting that education for the
people is fundamental to democracy and democratization.
First, what is the problem with education in Indonesia?
Well, the problems are complex and chronic. But we have to
make a start. The real problem is the non-existence of a
blueprint for the type of Indonesian we want in the future.
Forget about the rhetoric of masyarakat yang adil dan makmur (a
just and prosperous community), as coined in the Constitution.
One needs to translate this visionary statement into pieces
that ordinary people can understand and put into practice. First,
we have to make a statement about what sort of Indonesian do we
want, say, in 50 or 100 years from now? The last four and a half
years have clearly shown Indonesians to be all sorts of things,
though they haven't prepared them to be world citizens that will
be counted.
The "Education Blueprint" would define the path toward making
the sort of Indonesians that we want to see; the ones that will
be not only counted and reckoned with in the world, but indeed
will be leaders in many facets of worldly and religious
activities.
The Education Blueprint should comprise the short, medium and
strategic, or long-term, all of which should be interrelated and
all of which should interact to optimize every solution that
emanates from such a blueprint.
Essentially, education has five major aspects. These include
the curriculum, the teacher, the teaching method, the facilities
and of course the pupil. A systematic approach would require that
these five aspects be considered conjointly.
Improvement in only one of these areas will not ensure the
optimization of education. This explains why, for example, the
declaration of the nine-year compulsory basic education plan has
not worked. The lack or inexistence of a national goal for
education also will not improve anything.
This is a full circle back to the question of what sort of
Indonesians do we want in, say, 2100? Without such a target,
education or anything else, will flounder aimlessly. Thus the
Education Blueprint can only be promulgated once the whole
country knows where it's going.
If by 2100 we want Indonesians who are able to do this, that
and the other, then we can start putting together blueprints in
education, trade, foreign affairs, the economy and so on, which
will achieve these overall and national target(s).
If the National Development Planning Board (Bappenas) is the
agency that should do this, then it should also come up with
implementation processes, so that a synergic and comprehensive
result is achieved for the whole country.
It is this agency, not the legislative bodies that should
propose the percentage of budget to be given to any particular
portfolio, because we cannot afford just to deal with the
problems of the country in a piecemeal manner.
The curriculum would set the scene for what is to be learned
and to where the pupils are being guided. The overall guidance
here is the type of Indonesians we want to see in 50 or a 100
years from now. Forget about education theory, because these
theories may not be applicable for the target at hand.
Those theories were developed in other countries to solve or
rationalize situations and conditions in those countries. The
Ministry of National Education must therefore start by
translating the national target for the type of Indonesians we
want in the future into edible chunks in the curriculum.
Ideally, the ministry would also thus develop the short,
medium and long term parts of the curriculum. The short term
would address immediate issues to bring pupils to an acceptable
level of citizenry, the medium term considering more strategic
issues in preparing citizens for the longer-term period, and the
long term providing more basics in knowledge creation.
A possible short-term curriculum is a concentration on basic
ethics taught both explicitly perhaps as a subject, but also
implicitly in other subjects. Subjects taught here should also
reflect the needs for modern technology and applications, even to
the extent that little theory is included, as long as the
graduating pupils are able to practically and intellectually
immerse themselves in the technological currency of the world.
This curriculum should concentrate only on five or six
subjects and should be free of ideological studies, including
religion. Let parents send their children to religious lessons
outside of school if they feel so inclined.
The above should lead to the necessary preparation of the
teachers which should be reflected in the teacher training
curriculum. It should emphasizing practical training first, the
pedagogical later. The same argument behind the curriculum for
pupils applies to the curriculum for teacher training.
Part of the teacher training curriculum must include teaching
methodology, and the most appropriate methodology for each of the
three terms must be found and practiced. A more empowering
methodology is desirable, as this would allow pupils and students
to be more self-confident and self-sufficient. Self-confidence
and self-sufficiency are basic manifestations of empowerment,
while an empowered citizenry is basic to changing the paradigms
of living as a whole. In a world that is rapidly and increasingly
changing paradigms, Indonesia must also become an active player.
Schools do not need to be brick and mortar. People learn in
many ways. The concept that everyone has to be together
physically to learn, and the concept that pupils must see their
teachers physically in order to learn are gone.
Do we want to cling to the traditional concept of learning,
and thus the facilities that go with it, or do we leapfrog into
the 21st century and reap the benefits that come with it?
Indonesia needs some miracles to raise the educational level of
its citizens, and leapfrogging to current technology in education
is one of them. However, this requires different sorts of
facilities and some heavy investment may need to be made. This
should not, nevertheless, pose a hurdle.
Pupils should be empowered. Empowerment is not an abdication
of their responsibilities, and not a loss of power on the part of
teachers. Empowerment is making people responsible by allowing
them to make decisions and learn from their own decisions. It is
making men and women out of boys and girls. Indonesia needs real
and educated men and women who will lay the foundation for the
Indonesian of the future.
More from 28 September 2002 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/democracy-without-education-quo-vadis-1447893297-1227990)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post