Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Democracy vs efficiency at WTO

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Democracy vs efficiency at WTO

By Djauhari Oratmangun

This is the second of two articles.

GENEVA (JP): What lessons from the Singapore Ministerial
Conference-WTO can we expect to characterize future multilateral
trade negotiations within the WTO system?

First, negotiations within the WTO system -- including in the
future Ministerial Conference and in the various WTO bodies and
committees -- will be conducted in a more businesslike manner. In
other words greater efficiency will continue to be the main
characteristic in multilateral trade negotiations.

Second, since the WTO has a contractual and binding agreement,
economic and political pressure from the major trading nations to
include what they consider to be trade-related issues within the
WTO agreement will continue.

What transpired from the Singapore conference was obvious,
especially in the discussion of new issues such as investment,
competition policy and government procurement in the Ministerial
Declaration.

One of the main characteristics of the "contractual and
binding agreement" is that countries which have signed the
agreement and yet implement trade regulations or policies that
are inconsistent with the agreement can be brought before the WTO
Dispute Settlement Mechanism; in the event that they lose their
case, complainants are allowed to ask for compensation, or to
retaliate not only on the disputed product but also on other
products (cross retaliation concept).

Therefore, some developing countries have cynically said that
"the majors" want to bring everything under the sun to the WTO.
Or in plain terms, the agenda of the WTO is actually set up by
the majors.

Third, the WTO Secretariat, and in particular the director
general, play an important role in negotiations, more
particularly on the issues to be negotiated.

For example, the economist who preferred quiet negotiations,
DG Arthur Dunkel, came up with the "draft final act", the embryo
of the whole WTO Agreement; the dynamic and determined Peter
Sutherland, for his part brought some fresh blood into the
negotiations as well as political impetus and media attention to
conclude the seven-year long URMTN (Uruguay Round of Multilateral
Trade Negotiations); and as for the current developing group,
Renato Ruggiero, he pursued with considerable persistence in his
letter to the chairman of the Singapore Ministerial Conference
and with the blessing of the major trading nations, the inclusion
of the new issues (investment competition policy, government,
labor standards on the agenda), after the ambassador in Geneva
failed to reach a consensus on these issues.

Fourth, the ability and diplomatic skill of the chairman were
very instrumental in assuring the success of the meeting. In the
case of the WTO Singapore Ministerial Conference, the "stature"
of the host country and, in particular, the latter's role in
international trade, carried considerable weight.

Fifth, bearing in mind that every country has its own specific
trade interest, by definition it is difficult to form a solid
developing country group in the negotiation to ensure
transparency and to defend its agenda and interests when
individual countries sitting on the small group meeting are more
likely to end up fighting for their own trade interests over
those of their partners in the group.

The next question is: who then are the main players in the WTO
negotiation process, and what position should the developing
countries adopt in relation to them?

The players with the greatest influence on the nature of the
WTO negotiations are the groups representing the trade and
political interests of the major trading nations such as QUAD for
instance, with members such as the U.S., the EU, Canada and
Japan, or the G-7.

For example, after periods of stalemate, the URMTN resumed
again after the QUAD meeting in Tokyo in July 1993; the signing
of the Agreement on Information Technology agreed in Singapore
(with the QUAD as the main proponent); or the recent "basic
telecommunication pact" agreed in Geneva on Feb. 15, 1997 etc.

Another main player is the "silent" player with the "constant
insistence", i.e. the Secretariat of the WTO and, in particular,
its director general. The result of the Singapore Ministerial
Conference as contained in the Ministerial Declaration consists
almost entirely of the issues which have been persistently
brought up by the major trading nations and the developing group.

Issues such as trade and environment, investment, competition
policy, government procurement, labor standards, and even the
"plurilateral agreement on information technology", received the
most attention from the Singapore Ministerial Conference and the
western media; whereas issues such as the review of the
implementation of the Uruguay Round agreement, which is supposed
to be the mandate of the Ministerial Conference, or textiles and
agriculture, which are so close to the hearts of most developing
countries, did not receive the attention they deserve.

Therefore it is quite obvious that the agenda of the WTO is in
fact set up by the major trading nations with the blessing of the
developing group, or the other way around.

For the developing countries, the establishment of the WTO as
the watchdog against unfair trade practices ensures that their
interests will at least be on the agenda. It is better to have a
system, even if it still tends to accommodate the interests of
the major trading nations, rather than doing trade without any
rule-based system.

Therefore the positive approach of Singapore's trade and
industry minister Yeo and the developing group, Renato Ruggiero,
and their promise to bring transparency and wider participation
in the decision-making process in the WTO or to strike a balance
between democracy and efficiency -- should be supported, even
though it will not be easy to reach since, as rightly pointed out
by some developing countries' NGOs "at the most the problem is a
rule-based system, however the system is being ruled by the
power".

If the developing countries continue to believe that trade is
an engine of economic development, then we need to keep fighting
for a more equal share in the international trade arena. The WTO
in fact, with its rule-based system, could be used as much as
possible to achieve that goal.

In this regard, what the developing countries should do first
is to argue that the ministers want to increase the developing
countries participation in the system. This would ensure the
multilateral character of the WTO. At the same time it would
argue in favor of member states, as well as the WTO, of doing
their utmost in order to dispel the increasing feeling among the
smaller trading nations and the general public in the developing
countries that, in the rule-based system, the giants are above
the rules. It would also dispel the growing impression that the
major trading nations, particularly the U.S. and the EC, as well
as the WTO staff and developing group, returned from Singapore
feeling happy at having achieved what they set out to do -- while
the developing countries came back with nothing.

This coming month will be crucial, in particular with regard
to discussing new issues such as investment, competition policy
and government procurement at the new "working group" which is
going to be established as a follow-up to the Singapore
Ministerial Declaration.

This is so because it will set a model for future
deliberations or even negotiations in the WTO, and whether the
latter will continue to maintain the current way of doing
business, or whether it will change enough to gradually erase the
old image from the GATT era to the effect that the multilateral
trading system is a rich man's club.

The writer is an Indonesian diplomat based in Geneva. The
views expressed are strictly personal.

More from 12 March 1997 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/democracy-vs-efficiency-at-wto-1447893297-1526836)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print