Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Democracy in peril

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Democracy in peril

Indonesia is often described by international media and even
by world leaders such as U.S. President George W. Bush as the
world's third largest democracy, after India and the United
States. And Indonesians ought to be proud of this. Though still
economically poor, nonetheless Indonesia has laid the political
foundations for future progress.

Indonesia -- the fourth largest nation in the world by
population, and the world's largest Muslim nation -- succeeded
in not only ridding itself of former New Order dictator Soeharto,
after 32 years of suffocating control, but also succeeded in
conducting peaceful and democratic legislative elections in 1999
and 2004, as well as the nation's first direct presidential
elections last year.

Late last week, the Asian Development Bank in Indonesia
released its Country Governance Assessment Report. The first
paragraph of this report is quite disturbing, especially to those
amongst us who take pride in our democratic nation.

But we must be mature when responding to the bank's rather
sharp assessments. Reading it carefully, it is hard to deny their
findings as we know them to be true.

The bank has warned Indonesia that while its basic democratic
institutions have begun to take root, it is still far from having
a fully developed democracy with an administration and judiciary
based on rule of law, and a market economy based on fair and open
competition.

The bank blamed poorly managed state institutions as the
biggest obstacles to real democracy. It argues that Indonesia's
government previously operated under a regime in which state
institutions neglected good governance and rule of law, and where
narrow sectional interests was allowed to rule over the common
interest.

"These same institutions should now secure democracy, support
a market economy, and provide good governance," said the report.

It is too often said that Indonesia is one of the most corrupt
nations in the world. We no longer feel offended when foreign
investors criticize the "lawlessness" of our country.

Many Indonesians believe that our democracy is every bit as
advanced as that of the United States. Many of us are perhaps
unaware that democracy is in fact quite a complex concept, and
what we have achieved thus far is really just one part of the
system needed to build a sustainable democratic society.

We have made great progress, but our democracy is still
fragile.

The institutions of a modern democratic state are divided into
the judicial, legislative and the executive branches. They
include the House of Representatives (DPR), Supreme Court,
ministries, state agencies, Attorney General's Office and
National Police. It is very difficult indeed to defend any of
these institutions from the widespread perception that they are
riddled with corruption. Many people even say that corruption in
the post-Soeharto era is far more blatant, and that white-collar
criminals have lost all sense of shame.

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has repeatedly pledged that
the eradication of corruption would be his top priority. The
public now realizes that it is easier to promise than to deliver.
We believe that the President is completely sincere in his
intention, but when other state institutions are still managed in
the same manner as they were under Soeharto, can we expect them
to reform themselves?

It is nearly too much to expect that the police, courts, state
prosecutors and other law officers have the capability and
goodwill to assist the President create good governance, because
what they are practicing now is not much different from what they
were doing under Soeharto.

Shoddy, haphazard lawmaking also undermines efforts to build
good governance regimes. Law No. 36/1999 on telecommunications,
for instance, was hastily drafted and almost immediately approved
the House, only needing two weeks of deliberation. The law is
full of holes, so how can it be expected to be enforced? And how
can we expect good governance when practices such as having "off-
budget funds" are still rampant in many state offices.

Unless the government succeeds in reforming state institutions
-- and precious little progress has been made in this respect
over the last six years, despite international assistance -- our
democracy will remain in danger, because the sustainability of a
democratic state is not determined just by its ability to
organize elections, but also by good governance practices.

More from 4 March 2005 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/democracy-in-peril-1447893297-1150192)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print