Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Delay passage of broadcasting bill

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Delay passage of broadcasting bill

Ardimas, Staff Writer, Jakarta, ardimas@thejakartapost.com

The new, reform-minded broadcasting bill now being deliberated
by the House of Representatives (DPR), along with 42 others, is
another test case for President Megawati Soekarnoputri's
leadership and wisdom in handling the complexities of real
politik.

Deliberations on the bill, which will be used to replace
Broadcasting Bill No. 24/1997, began two years ago, and was
delayed by strong opposition from the media industry. Its
deliberation was further prolonged by a Cabinet shake-up as a
result of the transfer of power from Abdurrahman Wahid to
Megawati in July last year.

Executives and owners of the media from the Broadcasting
Television Association (ATVSI), the Association of Television
Journalists (AJTI) and the Press Council, have questioned some
contentious articles in the proposed bill. They suspected a
government hidden agenda to control the media through the
introduction of the draconian bill, a charge denied by the
government.

The Jakarta Post of Sept. 5 identified the controversial
articles in the bill: The setting up of the broadcasting
commission to be tasked with regulating the activities of all
broadcasting stations, foreign ownership in private stations,
cross-ownership between electronic and print media, licensing
mechanisms and periods, broadcasting content and limitations on
relays from foreign stations by local radio and television
stations.

Opposition from the media to the bill, which is scheduled to
be endorsed by the House on Nov. 25, can be divided into two main
types: Objections by the media as a pure business entity to
restrictions on its growth and fears of a repeat of media
repression, as in the past. Answers to these questions are key to
the current impasse in the endless debate on the bill.

The press regained its lost freedom after more than 30 years
with the fall of former president Soeharto in May 1998. Even now
the trauma left by bitter experiences can still be seen in the
way the big media treat "sensitive" events. In effect they handle
this type of news with kid gloves.

The attitude adopted by the media, especially giant groups
where thousands of people work and the owners and executives rake
in huge profits, is understood in view of their gloomy
experience. Media organizations such as the Press Council, the
Indonesian Journalists' Association and the Indonesian Publishers
Association were used by the government to muzzle the press.

Publications critical of the authorities were banned.
Outspoken and reform-minded journalists were prohibited from
assuming key positions in their own media due to legal procedures
requesting media to appoint "cooperative" personalities, expected
to be loyal to the government.

The New Order government used other mechanisms to control the
media through censorship, carried out by the Ministry of
Information, the production and distribution of ink and paper for
the print media and the allocation of frequencies for the
electronic media. The most effective way was, of course, the
licensing mechanism.

Opposition of the media to the proposed Broadcasting Bill
should not, therefore, be seen only from the perspective of press
freedom, but also from the angle of media ownership and the
political system brought about by changes in the political
context since the reform era.

As in the United States, media ownership here is now
concentrated in the hands of several individuals and groups. All
TV stations in the country, apart from state-owned TVRI, are, for
example, owned by the offspring, relatives or cronies of former
president Soeharto and figures close to senior executives of the
Golkar Party, which served as the political machine of the New
Order government, along with the military.

The practice of media conglomeration, such as seen in vertical
and horizontal integration through the acquisition of small media
and the publication of new media by big media groups, is one
indication of media concentration. Research done by the writer
this year indicated that the circulation of 10 major media groups
reached more than 70 percent of Indonesia's total media. The
remainder is shared by more than 500 print media. Two of the
largest media groups are Kompas and Tempo/Jawa Pos. Both groups'
total circulation reaches more than 40 percent for newspapers and
50 percent for magazines, comparable with media groups in the
U.S. Most of these groups owned more than one type of media --
newspapers, magazines, tabloids, TV stations or radio stations.

SCTV is owned by Sudwikatmono, president Soeharto's
stepbrother; Indosiar by Soedono Salim or Liem Sioe Liong (now
under the custodianship of the Indonesian Bank Restructuring
Agency); RCTI by Bambang Trihatmodjo, Soeharto's second son, from
the Bimantara Citra diversified business group; TPI by Siti
Hardiyanti Rukmana, Soeharto's eldest daughter; and ANTeve by
Agung Laksono of the Golkar central board and Aburizal Bakrie of
the Bakrie Group. The five stations, with RCTI the oldest private
TV station, were established between 1989 and 1991.

Newly established private television stations, such as Metro
TV, Trans TV, Lativi, Global TV and TV7 are run by large business
groups close to former New Order or media giants. Metro TV is
owned by Surya Paloh of Media Indonesia group, a large chunk of
its shares reportedly owned by Bambang Trihatmodjo; Lativi by
former minister of Manpower Abdul Latief; and TV7 by Kompas
Gramedia Group, one of Indonesia's largest media chains.

During the New Order era RCTI, SCTV, TPI, ANTeve and
Indosiar, as part of the capitalist system, received privileges
from the government such as easy licensing procedures, the right
to air their programs nationwide and the use of government
facilities. TPI, at the initial stage of its existence,
reportedly even used TVRI's relay facilities under the pretense
that the station was an educational television station supporting
government programs on distance learning.

The most invaluable gift received by privately owned TV
stations could be the government's decision to continue a ban on
TVRI from running advertisements, which had been in place since
1981. At the initial stage of the unpopular ban, advertising went
to the big print media such as the Sinar Harapan Group, Media
Indonesia, Pos Kota Group and Kompas Group. But since 1989 the
flow of ads shifted from the print media to private TV stations.
In return the private stations were required to pay a certain
amount of money to TVRI, an obligation partially or never
fulfilled by the owners of the private stations for a variety of
reasons and ignored by the government.

The writer received his masters degree in communication
science from the University of Indonesia, Jakarta.

More from 13 November 2002 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/delay-passage-of-broadcasting-bill-1447893297-1223527)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print