Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Defining and Reinforcing the Judicial Commission’s Oversight Authority over Judges

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Defining and Reinforcing the Judicial Commission’s Oversight Authority over Judges
Image: detikcom

“Law is established to bring about happiness and remove evil or harm. Every beneficial matter has therefore been prescribed, and every harmful matter must be eliminated.”

Under the concept of judicial power, the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court are designated as institutions exercising that power, with the task of administering justice to uphold the law and justice. The Constitution describes judicial power as “independent”, in keeping with the principle of judicial independence.

The 1945 Constitution places the Judicial Commission in Chapter IX on Judicial Power, alongside the Supreme Court, all types of courts under it and the Constitutional Court. Article 24B clearly sets out the Commission’s powers. The phrases “administering justice” and “upholding the law and justice” are linked to the concept of a state governed by the rule of law. Their application must accord with the constitutional values of law, namely “fair legal certainty”. This means that legal certainty encompasses both procedural and substantive justice.

The Judicial Commission’s authority to safeguard and uphold judges’ honour, dignity and conduct at every level is a specific power. This special remit concerns judicial accountability, which is a key component of Indonesia’s system of the separation of powers in its formal sense. However, judicial accountability cannot be understood as unlimited power. Judicial independence must go hand in hand with accountability, which serves to ensure an independent and impartial judiciary. Judges’ independence and impartiality are therefore not solely matters for the judiciary itself; they are also part of the recognition, guarantee and protection of everyone’s rights in the enforcement of the law. Law enforcement must ensure both procedural and substantive justice.

In relation to the supremacy of law, the Judicial Commission’s enforcement of ethical standards is important to achieving judicial independence. Law enforcement grounded in ethics produces outcomes that are not only formally legal but also morally legitimate. This is an absolute prerequisite for upholding the rule of law. The Judicial Commission’s authority to enforce judicial ethics and conduct under Article 24B of the 1945 Constitution is therefore a specific power.

The distinction between specific and general authority can be understood through the fiqh principle, “Al-wilayah al-khasshah aqwa min al-wilayah al-’ammah” (specific authority is stronger than general authority). The judiciary’s role in administering justice and upholding the law is a form of general authority (wilayah al-’ammah), covering a broad range of legal matters. By contrast, wilayah al-khasshah is its opposite. A specific expression indicates a definitive meaning and does not admit other interpretations.

Where specific and general powers overlap, the specific power takes precedence. In the current dualism between the Supreme Court and the Judicial Commission over the enforcement of judicial ethics and conduct, this fiqh principle provides a point of reference. The Constitution mandates that the Commission safeguard and uphold judges’ honour, dignity and conduct. “Safeguarding” entails prevention, while “upholding” refers to corrective and repressive action. The mandate concerning judges’ honour, dignity and conduct cannot be interpreted as general: it applies specifically to individual judges. Judicial accountability is likewise specific. Under the principle that specific authority is stronger than general authority, the Judicial Commission holds the specific power to realise accountability through its oversight function. That function must not be interpreted as extending into the judiciary’s general role of upholding the law and justice.

The Judicial Commission’s specific authority is intended to serve the public interest and must therefore be fulfilled. Another fiqh principle states, “Al-maslahah al-’ammah muqaddamah ’ala al-maslahah al-khassah” (the public interest must take precedence over private or particular interests). Accordingly, the Commission’s specific authority should be prioritised to realise the public interest (al-maslahah al-’ammah). This public interest accords with general justice (justitia generalis), in which justice required by law must be delivered for the common good.

The public interest in an independent and impartial judiciary lies in extending to society the constitutional value of “fair legal certainty”. It also encompasses the legal interests that must be protected: not only individual interests (individuale belangen), but also social interests (sosiale belangen) and state interests (staats belangen).

It is important to emphasise that public benefit is universal, not partial. In other words, it is a right and responsibility shared by all humanity, without limitation by any particular group or interest. In line with this, Jeremy Bentham, a pioneer of utilitarianism, argued that the sole purpose of law is to bring the greatest possible happiness or benefit to the greatest number of people. In short, this is the principle of “the greatest happiness”.

The utilitarian aim of realising public benefit is incomplete without protection against harm. A related fiqh principle says, “Ad-dararu yuzal” (harm must be eliminated). This means that all forms of harm must be removed. The principle aims to protect people from various dangers and forms of damage, and to promote public benefit. Another principle states, “Ad-dhararu yudfau ’ala qadril imkan” (harm should be removed to the greatest extent possible, even if it cannot be eliminated entirely). A further principle holds that “dar’u al-mafasid muqaddam ’ala jalbi al-mashalih” (preventing harm takes precedence over securing benefit).

Consistent with these principles of harm prevention, judicial accountability is intended to prevent harm in the administration of justice. The public interest must therefore produce benefit rather than harm. The public-interest approach is strategic and important because it connects collective interests with the prevention of harm.

The Judicial Commission’s oversight is a “complement to judicial power”, intended to ensure an independent and impartial judiciary. Its remit concerns judges’ ethics and conduct. This accords with the principle, “ma la yatimmu al-wajib illa bihi fahuwa wajib” (whatever is necessary to fulfil an obligation is itself obligatory). Establishing an independent judiciary is an obligation in a state governed by the rule of law, and achieving it requires oversight by the Judicial Commission. The Commission is needed to complement judicial power through its oversight function. Without comprehensive oversight by the Commission, the judiciary cannot exercise its power and cannot be independent.

More from 4 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/defining-and-reinforcing-the-judicial-commissions-oversight-authority-over-judges-1793757065)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8737346/pembatas-dan-penegas-kewenangan-pengawasan-hakim-oleh-komisi-yudisial), translated from Indonesian
Print