Deciles Change According to Economic Conditions, Meaning Social Assistance Is Not Guaranteed?
The government claims that the grouping of deciles within the National Single Social and Economic Data (DTSEN) is being progressively updated through the correction of DTSEN Volume 3.1.
Minister of Social Affairs Saifullah Yusuf stated that the latest update was conducted after the Central Bureau of Statistics (BPS) obtained verification and validation data from the BKKBN, amounting to 12 million new data entries. “New data from BKKBN had entered without being verified and validated, causing fluctuations. Now, it has been stabilised, tidied, verified, and validated. God willing, in the next 1-2 weeks, this data will become even more accurate,” said the minister, commonly known as Gus Ipul, in a written statement on Friday.
Gus Ipul emphasised that a change in decile does not immediately result in an individual being removed from the social assistance (bansos) recipient list. He stressed that the distribution of aid still awaits the official determination of recipients for each distribution period.
“Therefore, it is not as if someone whose decile changes is automatically struck off. We are still waiting for the determination at the start of the distribution month. For example, even if there are surges, the aid does not automatically disappear because we have not yet distributed it. Meanwhile, for PBI (Health Insurance Recipients), it is processed monthly,” Gus Iroc asserted.
Andy Kurniawan, an expert advisor to the Minister of Social Affairs for Strategic Policy Planning and Evaluation, explained that DTSEN deciles are not a direct measure of wealth or specific income levels. Deciles represent a relative ranking of the population’s welfare levels nationwide. After being ranked from the lowest to the highest level of welfare, the population is divided into 10 groups known as deciles.
“Deciles are not a certificate of being rich or poor. Deciles cannot be equated directly with income. You cannot say Decile 1 earns this much or Decile 10 earns that much,” said Andy.
Because the system is relative, an individual’s decile position can change even if their personal economic condition remains unchanged. This can occur because the economic status of other families in the national ranking has shifted. “For instance, if there is a disaster in Sumatra causing many people to fall into poverty, my decile will automatically rise. Because when re-ranked nationally, if some people move down, others will move up (in decile rank),” he explained.
Andy noted that the DTSEN is updated every three months, resulting in four data versions per year. The significant changes in Volume 3 occurred following the inclusion of approximately 12 million new data points from the BKKBN. He suggested that the issue of changing deciles became widely discussed because it coincided with the university registration period related to the Indonesia Smart Card (KIP), alongside the update to DTSEN Volume 3.
“These 12 million new data points are the source of the update in volume three. This update caused the fluctuations in deciles to feel very significant. BPS has evaluated this, and we are directly addressing the specific cases arising in the community,” said Andy.
He further emphasised that deciles are not the primary requirement for receiving social assistance. Deciles serve as one of the considerations for determining priority, while each specific programme has its own recipient criteria. “For example, if there are 10 people in a room entitled to aid, but the government only has funds for 5, the decile functions to select those 5. Those in Decile 1 certainly take priority over those in Decile 4, and Decile 4 takes priority over Decile 5. That is how priority is determined.”
Furthermore, recipient criteria are tied to each specific programme. For instance, even if someone is in Deciles 1 to 4—the priority group for PKH (Family Hope Programme)—they cannot receive aid if they fail to meet other criteria, such as being a civil servant (PNS).
An increase in decile does not automatically mean a person has become wealthier or has lost their right to social assistance. The determination of recipients still considers programme criteria and available quotas. “The notion that if your decile rises, you become richer and your aid disappears, is entirely incorrect. And the perception that if aid disappears, it is because it has been revoked or diverted to other programmes, is also untrue. The total amount of social assistance remains the same or even increases. The reason some eligible people do not receive aid is simply due to limited quotas,” Andy explained.
Regarding the data changes in DTSEN Volume 3, BPS has released DTSEN Volume 3.1 as a correction to fix the significant spikes in decile changes previously observed.
Citizens who feel their data is inaccurate in the DTSEN can request an update through their village or sub-district government with the assistance of the SIKS-NG operator, via ground checks by PKH facilitators, BPS, or local governments, or independently through the Cek Bansos application.
Updates can also be made via the call centre at 021-171, WhatsApp at 08877-171-171, and online channels at dtsen-form.bps.go.id and perlinsos.kemensos.go.id.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/deciles-change-according-to-economic-conditions-meaning-social-assistance-is-not-guaranteed-1788533860)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260904160941-4-765044/desil-berubah-sesuai-kondisi-ekonomi-jadi-tak-pasti-dapat-bansos), translated from Indonesian