Debt Collection Accompanied by Threats Can Be a Criminal Offence, UI Expert Says
Jakarta (ANTARA) – University of Indonesia (UI) criminal law expert Flora Dianti said debt collection accompanied by coercion, violence or threats may constitute a criminal offence, as stipulated in Articles 482 and 483 of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code (KUHP).
Flora made the statement while appearing as an expert witness at a hearing in the alleged extortion case against defendant Bangun Paulus Tudungta at the Central Jakarta District Court on Wednesday (21 October).
“The core of Articles 482 and 483 is coercion. The crime takes the form of someone being forced,” Flora said in a written statement received in Jakarta on Thursday.
She explained that Article 482 concerns extortion through violence or threats of violence, while Article 483 covers extortion through threats to reveal a secret or to defame someone.
“When collecting a debt, you simply collect the debt; there is no need for coercion, threats or extortion. But if there are threats and money is extorted, that amounts to an abuse of rights,” Flora said.
She added that threats are not always made openly, but can be assessed through conversations, written messages or body gestures, taking the context of the incident into account.
“A threat makes the victim feel afraid. That fear ultimately leads the victim to hand over property, so there is a causal link. Of course, the fear must be assessed in light of the threat,” Flora said.
After the hearing, prosecutor Andri Saputra said the expert’s testimony strengthened the indictment against the defendant.
The defendant, meanwhile, did not respond to the expert’s testimony during the hearing.
“In principle, in my view, the expert’s testimony strengthens the indictment. That is all,” Andri said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/debt-collection-accompanied-by-threats-can-be-a-criminal-offence-ui-expert-says-1792630324)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5803561/ahli-ui-sebut-penagihan-utang-disertai-ancaman-bisa-dipidana), translated from Indonesian