Debate Over 'BRAN' Nomenclature in Agrarian Reform Bill Leads Deputy Minister to Request Delay
Members of the DPR Legislation Committee (Baleg) engaged in a debate with the government regarding the nomenclature of a new agency intended to manage agrarian reform regulations during the discussion of the List of Problems (DIM) for the Agrarian Reform Regulation Bill. The Committee requested that the nomenclature of the agency be explicitly included within the law.
The debate took/occurred during a meeting at the DPR Legislation Committee in Jakarta on Friday (18/09/2026). The issue was raised by the Vice Chairman of the Committee, Sturman Panjaitan, who highlighted that Article 11 of the Agrarian Reform Bill does not specify the clear name of the intended agency.
“Permission, Chair, this is a recurring point. The determination of agrarian reform objects, as referred to in paragraph 2, is carried out based on the decision of a government agency, but which one?” asked Sturman.
“Does it mean BRAN…” added another Vice Chairman, Iman Sukri.
“Why not just mention BRAN?” Sturman questioned again.
“It hasn’t been decided yet, as the government will establish it through a Presidential Regulation (Perpres),” Iman Sukri replied.
Sturman expressed confusion over this, questioning the hierarchy of laws where a Presidential Regulation is subordinate to an Act (UU).
“It is exhausting to wait for this. We are drafting a law, so why are we waiting for a Presidential Regulation? It is strange. We create the law, and the derivatives of the law are the Presidential Regulations, Government Regulations, and so on. Why are we waiting for a Presidential Regulation? It is bizarre, in my opinion,” Sturman asserted.
“This refers to BRAN, Chair,” Iman Sukri interjected.
“That is not possible. Show me where it says ‘to be determined by the government’. It is quite ridiculous,” Sturman pressed.
Sturman questioned why the agency’s nomenclature must wait for the government, noting that the Agrarian Reform Bill is a product of the DPR RI.
“What is the name? Waiting… waiting for the government? How ridiculous. How can a law wait for a Presidential Regulation? Using a microphone, Sir. Use the microphone, Sir, so we can be clear about this process,” Sturpend Sturman.
Representing the government, the Deputy Minister of State Secretariat, Bambang Eko Suhariyanto, responded by citing Article 25, paragraph 3 of the State Ministry Law (Law Number 1 of 2024), which states that non-structural agencies or other government agencies are positioned and responsible as determined by the President or in accordance with statutory provisions, with further provisions regulated by Presidential Regulation.
“Therefore, based on this law, we never include the specific nomenclature of any institutional body within an Act. We limit it so that if at any time—since this is an executive matter—the President wishes, for example, ‘I feel this name is not appropriate’, it can be changed at any time via Presidential Regulation. But if it is in the Act, Sir, it is just nomenclature, not the functions,” Bambang explained.
“The functions and authorities will remain, right?” asked the Chairman of the Committee, Bob Hasan.
“They will, Sir,” replied Bambang.
Iman Sukri countered that the cited law was less relevant, arguing that the preceding paragraph suggested the formation of the agency was not entirely left to the President’s discretion.
Deputy Minister Bambang responded by stating that this aligned with the wishes of President Prabowo Subianto.
“Sir, I must say this. This was originally the President’s wish, so that he has the freedom to name the agency or whatever it may be, rather than being restricted,” Bambang clarified.
“The point is, if possible, the agency should not be regulated within the Act. The name, Sir, the name. So that he has the freedom to name it whatever he wants. That is why…” he continued.
Bob Hasan expressed agreement with the Deputy Minister of State Secretariat. He proposed that the agency be written as a body at the ministerial level, reporting directly to the President. Bob also requested that the debate in the Committee not be prolonged. Vice Chairman Iman Sukri then proposed that Article 11 of the Bill be bypassed for the time being.
Input also came from another Committee member, Benny K. Harman, who requested that the government first discuss the proposed nomenclature. During the session, the Deputy Minister requested that the nomenclature not be regulated by the DPR.
“That is correct. To reinforce the President’s directive, the State Secretariat will send a letter to all institutions stating that when discussing laws and such, the nomenclature should not be regulated within the law. Let that be the President’s prerogative,” said Bambang.
“Yes, yes. Please explain this, Sir, so that our colleagues here do not harbour any prejudices, Sir. Because the law must be logical and systematic,” Bob added.
A number of Committee members insisted that the nomenclature be included in the Agrarian Reform Act. Deputy Minister Bambang then requested that the nomenclature issue be postponed.
“With your permission, Sir, because this has already been reported as approved, and now it has been reopened. We request time, Sir, for consultation because, without it, we do not dare to decide on this. So, let us postpone it, Sir. Thank you,” said Bambang.
“Yes, Sir, certainly. While we consult, we shall proceed to DIM 297,” replied Iman Sukri.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/debate-over-bran-nomenclature-in-agrarian-reform-bill-leads-deputy-minister-to-request-delay-1789732658)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8668959/debat-nomenklatur-bran-di-rapat-ruu-reforma-agraria-wamen-minta-pending), translated from Indonesian