Crypto Fatwa in the Tokenisation Era: Time for a New Paradigm
Note: This article reflects the personal opinion of the author and does not represent the views of the CNBC Indonesia editorial team.
Over the past few years, discourse on cryptocurrency has almost always stopped at one question: halal or haram. Yet while that debate remains unresolved, the world has moved far ahead.
Blockchain is no longer synonymous with speculative assets; it has developed into new infrastructure for the financial system through asset tokenisation, namely the transformation of ownership rights over real assets into digital representations. Government bonds, sukuk, shares, gold, property, investment funds and even carbon credits are beginning to be tokenised as a new foundation for financial markets.
This change is not merely technological innovation, but a paradigm shift. The Bank for International Settlements (BIS), the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the European Central Bank (ECB) and various central banks around the world now place tokenisation at the heart of financial system modernisation.
Through Project Guardian, the Monetary Authority of Singapore is testing the tokenisation of bonds, investment funds and bank deposits, whilst BlackRock, through BUIDL, has shown how government securities can be represented in the form of digital tokens.
The world’s focus is no longer on questioning whether blockchain is necessary, but on how to build governance that guarantees security, transparency and trust. Indonesia is entering the same phase. Since oversight of crypto assets shifted to the Financial Services Authority (OJK) under the P2SK Law, digital assets have entered a stage of institutionalisation.
With more than 20 million consumers, transaction values exceeding Rp650 trillion, and one of the highest crypto adoption rates in the world, the main challenge is no longer accepting or rejecting digital assets, but building governance capable of turning the sheer size of that market into an ecosystem that is safe, productive and has integrity.
It is in this context that the Fatwa of the VII Indonesian Ulama Commission Fatwa Assembly of 2021 concerning cryptocurrency deserves to be re-read. Not to be pitted against technological development, but to be contextualised now that blockchain has evolved from a speculative instrument into financial infrastructure.
The relevant question is no longer whether cryptocurrency is halal or haram, but how to ensure that asset tokenisation proceeds in accordance with sharia principles, with legal integrity, technological security, and benefits for the economy.
The Fatwa as an Ethical Compass
When the fatwa was issued, the market was indeed dominated by highly volatile cryptocurrencies with minimal underlying assets and rife with speculation. In that context, the Ulama Assembly Fatwa stated that the use of cryptocurrency as currency is not permitted because it contravenes Indonesia’s positive law and contains elements of gharar (uncertainty) and dharar (harm).
However, the fatwa does not close the door entirely. Digital assets that qualify as sil’ah (tradeable commodities), possess underlying assets, and are free from gharar, dharar and qimar (gambling) are deemed tradeable under sharia.
This formulation shows that the object of assessment is not blockchain technology, but the economic substance of the transaction. What is tested is the existence of underlying assets, the clarity of ownership rights, the contract structure, and the potential for harm. The fatwa is therefore best understood as an ethical compass for financial innovation rather than a rejection of technology.
From Securitisation to Tokenisation
Tokenisation is often perceived as an entirely new phenomenon. In economic terms, however, it is an evolution of a long-established concept: asset securitisation.
If securitisation converts assets or cash flows into tradable instruments, tokenisation converts the representation of ownership or benefits over those assets into a digital, blockchain-based form. What changes is not the economic rights, but the medium through which those rights are represented.
In Islamic finance, this logic has long been recognised through various asset-based and benefit-based sukuk structures, in which investors obtain economic rights over real assets through valid contracts. Tokenisation brings the same principle into the digital era.
The difference lies not in economic substance but in infrastructure. Centralised registries, custodians and settlement processes are replaced by distributed ledger technology, enabling the recording of ownership and the transfer of rights to take place more quickly, transparently and programmably.
On this basis, this article proposes a Digital Securitization Paradigm: a way of viewing tokenisation as the digital evolution of asset securitisation, not as an entirely new concept. This paradigm shifts the focus of assessment from the technology to the substance of the legal and economic relationships built upon it.
This paradigm has important implications for fiqh muamalah. Sharia assessment no longer stops at the question of whether blockchain can be accepted, but shifts to the substance of the legal and economic relationships constructed.
What must be tested is the legality of the underlying asset, clarity of ownership rights, validity of contracts, transparency of rights transfer, and freedom from riba (usury), gharar, maysir (gambling), tadlis (deception) and dharar. This approach aligns with the fiqh principle that what matters is the essence and purpose of a contract, not merely its form or medium.
From this perspective, the 2021 Ulama Assembly Fatwa in fact has ample room for adaptation. When the fatwa requires underlying assets, clarity of transaction objects, and the absence of gharar, dharar and qimar, it is effectively laying an ethical foundation for the development of digital assets with a real economic base.
This approach also aligns with Douglas North’s thinking that economic growth is largely determined by the quality of institutions capable of creating certainty of rights and lowering transaction costs. In the context of tokenisation, blockchain is not a replacement for institutions, but an instrument that strengthens efficiency when placed under proper governance.
In line with this, Lawrence Lessig reminds us that code is law; in the digital economy, the architecture of technology helps shape market behaviour. For this reason, blockchain governance is as important as blockchain technology itself.
Learning from the World, Building Our Own Standards
Global developments show that regulators are no longer questioning the existence of blockchain, but how the technology is used to build financial systems that are more efficient, secure and trusted.
The BIS, through its Unified Ledger concept, proposes integrating central bank money, bank deposits and tokenised assets within a single digital infrastructure. Singapore, through Project Guardian, is testing the tokenisation of bonds, investment funds and various real-world assets.
The European Union, through the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation, classifies digital assets by function and risk, whilst tokens representing securities remain subject to the capital market regime. Malaysia is also developing digital asset regulation that runs in tandem with sharia assessment by its Shariah Advisory Council. The message is the same: governance matters more than technology.
Similar developments are beginning to appear in international Islamic finance discourse. To date, the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI) has not issued a Sharia Standard specifically regulating cryptocurrency or asset tokenisation.
However, the growing attention to digital financial innovation shows that the global Islamic finance community is moving towards more adaptive standards. Just as AAOIFI spent three decades building standards for sukuk and the sharia capital market, tokenisation also requires a gradual process of ijtihad, standardisation and governance.
The history of sukuk offers a valuable lesson. That instrument, too, sparked conceptual debate when it first emerged, before eventually gaining legitimacy through the refinement of contract structures, governance and sharia standards.
Tokenisation may well follow the same path. If sukuk was the result of sharia ijtihad on securitisation in the late 20th century, then tokenisation has the potential to become a new arena of ijtihad for Islamic finance in the 21st century.
From Fatwa to Governance
If governance is the paradigm required, then Indonesia needs a framework capable of integrating sharia principles, technological innovation and modern regulation. To that end, this article proposes a Sharia Digital Asset Governance Framework (SDAGF) resting on five pillars: legal integrity, sharia integrity, technological integrity, market integrity and societal impact.
These five dimensions ensure that the assessment of digital assets is no longer done in a piecemeal fashion. A token may satisfy the technological aspect, yet not necessarily meet sharia principles.
Conversely, a sharia-compliant contract structure also requires technological security, investor protection and market integrity in order to deliver genuine benefit. Thus, legal compliance, sharia compliance, technological security, market integrity and contribution to the real economy must be viewed as a single whole.
The ultimate goal is to build a Trusted Islamic Digital Asset Ecosystem (TIDAE): an ecosystem that makes trust its primary foundation. In this ecosystem, blockchain is positioned as infrastructure, regulation as the guardian of market integrity, and sharia as the ethical compass ensuring innovation remains oriented towards maqasid al-sharia, particularly the protection of wealth (hifz al-mal), justice (’adl), transparency (bayan) and public benefit (maslahah).
Indonesia has great assets to lead this agenda. The world’s largest Muslim population, a growing Islamic finance industry, a large digital asset market, and the strengthened regulatory framework following the P2SK Law form a strategic combination few other countries possess.
From Fatwa to an Architecture of Trust
If securitisation was the financial market innovation of the 20th century, then tokenisation is its digital evolution in the 21st. Sharia ijtihad therefore cannot stop at assessing cryptocurrency as an object, but must move towards building tokenisation governance that guarantees legality, integrity, transparency and benefit.
The 2021 Ulama Assembly Fatwa should not be understood as the end point of the discourse, but as an ethical foundation for reading each innovation according to the substance of its contracts and economic purpose. What needs updating is not the sharia principles themselves, but the way we understand the evolution of technology and the new forms of digital economic transactions.
In the end, the relevant question is no longer “is crypto halal or haram?” but “how do we build an architecture of trust for the digital economy?” That is where the future of Indonesian Islamic finance will be decided.
Not by how quickly we adopt technology, but by how well we ensure that every digital innovation operates within the corridors of law, governance and sharia values. If this foundation is successfully built, Indonesia has the opportunity not only to become one of the world’s largest digital asset markets, but also a global pioneer in sharia digital asset governance in the tokenisation era.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/crypto-fatwa-in-the-tokenisation-era-time-for-a-new-paradigm-1783871485)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260712213250-14-750237/fatwa-kripto-di-era-tokenisasi-saatnya-paradigma-baru), translated from Indonesian