Criticism Mounts as Indonesia Passes Revised Police Law
The Civil Society Coalition for Police Sector Reform has rejected the ratification of the third revision of Law Number 2 of 2002 concerning the Indonesian National Police (Polri). Representing the Coalition, Muhammad Isnur stated that this rejection stems from the fact that the newly passed Police Law is inconsistent with the mandate of police reform.
“The drafting process was also carried out haphazardly,” said Isnur in a written statement on Tuesday, 9 June 2026.
The Coalition assesses that the drafting process of the Police Bill by the Working Committee and the government ignored meaningful participation as regulated by law. Isnur noted that instead of being transparent and accountable, the drafting process was conducted behind closed doors.
One example is the absence of an official draft, which made it difficult for the public to monitor the bill’s discussion process. “The lack of transparency results in the closure of equal participation spaces between policymakers and the public,” said Isnur.
Rapid Deliberation
The Coalition further assessed that the drafting and discussion of the Police Bill were rushed. This is evident from the very short timeframe; the Police Bill was proposed as a DPR initiative on 20 May 2026 and was ratified into law on 9 June 2026.
Isnur warned that rushed deliberations would create problems and lead to legal challenges. He cited several problematic pieces of DPR legislation that were passed rapidly, including the KPK Law, the Job Creation Law, the TNI Law, and the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP). “The reckless ratification process instead gives rise to various serious problems in the future,” he said.
Placement of Active Personnel in Civilian Positions
Another provision in the Police Law highlighted by the Coalition is the placement of active police personnel in civilian positions. According to Isnably, this provision contradicts the MPR Decrees as well as the Constitutional Court Decision Number 114/PUU-XXIII/2025.
“The formulation of Article 28A of the Police Bill actually opens up such wide space for active police personnel to occupy civilian positions without clear limitations,” said Isnur.
However, the Chief of National Police, General Listyo Sigit Prabowo, stated that the placement of active personnel must receive approval from the relevant ministry. “There must be a request. If there is no request, the Police will not send personnel,” Listym said at the DPR Complex on Tuesday, 9 June 2026.
Extension of Retirement Age
The newly ratified Police Law also regulates the retirement age for police personnel. Under the new regulations, the retirement age for lower-ranking personnel (Tantama and Bintara) is set at a maximum of 59 years.
For officers, the maximum retirement age is 60 years. However, during the Level I decision-making process, the government proposed increasing the retirement age for high-ranking police officers with four-star rank to 61 years, based on necessity.
The Coalition is concerned that increasing the retirement age will hinder the process of personnel regeneration and lead to an increase in ‘non-job’ personnel. This provision is feared to add a budgetary burden that could erode the state’s fiscal position.
The Coalition also questioned several other provisions, such as Article 19A of the Police Law, which they claim demonstrates a failure in evaluating police accountability by relying solely on internal supervision.
The Police Bill was ratified into law during the 21st plenary session of the DPR on Tuesday, 9 June 2026. Deputy Minister of Law Edward Omar Sharif Hiariej, also known as Eddy Hiariej, invited members of the public who feel their constitutional rights have been violated by the Police Bill to file judicial reviews, either materially or formally, to the Constitutional Court.
He stated that the government, as the law-maker, does not dispute the criticisms presented by the public, including regarding the placement of active police members in civilian roles and the extension of the retirement age. “We accept criticism with open arms. However, there is an elegant channel [for recourse],” said Eddy.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/criticism-mounts-as-indonesia-passes-revised-police-law-1781056565)
Originally published by Tempo (Indonesian) (https://nasional.tempo.co/read/2107706/berbagai-kritik-pengesahan-ruu-polri), translated from Indonesian