Critical Notes on the Asset Forfeiture Bill from the Civil Society Coalition
The Civil Society Coalition has urged the DPR and the government to release the draft and Problem Inventory List (DIM) of the Asset Forfeiture Bill.
The coalition consists of Indonesia Corruption Watch, Auriga, Kaoem Telapak, the Centre for Law and Policy Studies (PSHK), the Anti-Corruption Study Centre (SAKSI) of the Faculty of Law at Mulawarman University, and Transparency International Indonesia.
“The Civil Society Coalition demands that the DPR and the Government immediately release the draft and DIM of the Asset Forfeiture Bill to the public through the official publication channels of the DPR RI to avoid confusing information and as an initial step towards implementing meaningful public participation in the legislative process,” said Wana Alamsyah from ICW in a press statement on Thursday (27/8).
Without transparency, Wana said, the potential clauses in the Asset Forfeiture Bill draft could actually weaken efforts to recover assets from criminal acts and provide benefits to certain groups that would escape broad public attention.
The coalition also asked the DPR to strengthen the provisions in the Asset Forfeiture Bill, especially regarding the forfeiture of illicit enrichment.
This is to ensure that assets belonging to public officials that are disproportionate to their income and whose lawful origins cannot be proven can be seized by the state.
Such forfeiture should also have clear subjects, parameters, and burden of proof stipulated in the articles, rather than being left to the interpretation of judges.
Furthermore, the coalition also asked the DPR to clarify the scope and procedural law for non-conviction based (NCB) forfeiture. This is to ensure that the Asset Forfeiture Bill can reach assets that have failed to be executed as well as ownerless assets, rather than merely stopping at the conceptual level.
“The DPR must design an accountable asset management institution with a single responsible party whose form and accountability are clear,” said Wana.
“This is to ensure that seized assets are not scattered among many institutions without cross-agency oversight and without accountability to the public,” he continued.
Three points of regression
The coalition identified at least three substantive regressions in the circulating DPR draft dated 10 July 2026 compared to the government’s draft.
First, the coalition suspects that the DPR removed the norm regarding illicit enrichment. Article 5 paragraph (2) of the government’s 2023 draft contained provisions for the forfeiture of assets that are disproportionate to income and whose lawful origins cannot be proven.
This provision is suspected to have been removed from the DPR’s version of the draft.
Yet this instrument is one that can target the wealth of public officials that is disproportionate to their official income.
In several corruption cases, there are indications that suspects arrested by law enforcement possess unreasonable wealth based on the State Officials’ Wealth Report (LHKPN).
Second, the coalition suspects that the DPR narrowed the scope of non-conviction based forfeiture.
The DPR draft regulates NCB in Article 3 letter b, with its conditions detailed in Article 6: the perpetrator has died, fled, is permanently ill, or the case cannot be brought to trial.
The problem, according to the coalition, is that all asset objects in Article 5 are always linked to the perpetrator of a criminal act. As a result, NCB in the DPR draft can in practice only be used when the perpetrator is known but cannot be prosecuted, and it becomes unclear whether it can be used to seize assets that have failed to be executed or ownerless assets.
This differs from the government’s draft.
Article 5 paragraph (1) letter d explicitly targets proceeds of crime whose perpetrator or owner is unknown, with examples of timber from illegal logging and online gambling proceeds in the explanatory notes. This clarity of scope is important so that NCB does not stop at the conceptual level, but can truly reach assets that have so far escaped criminal proceedings.
Third, the coalition suspects that the DPR left the asset management institution hanging without a clear responsible party.
The government’s 2023 draft had established a single responsible party, namely the Attorney General as the asset manager in accordance with Article 50. Meanwhile, the detailed duties (Article 51), a transparent asset information system (Article 60), and periodic reporting (Article 61) were also included in the government’s draft.
The DPR draft dismantles this clarity through three problems.
First, the managing institution is intangible. Article 46 mentions the Asset Management Agency as if the institution already exists. Yet the DPR draft never explains what it is, who leads it, under which institution it operates, and to whom it is accountable.
This article is considered inconsistent when compared with Articles 50 and 53, which grant authority to the National Police Chief, the Attorney General, and the Supreme Court to manage and submit periodic reports on assets under their control.
The unclear entity of the Asset Management Agency is also said to potentially become a source of authority disputes between the Asset Management Agency and the Attorney General’s Office Asset Management Agency in the future.
“In addition, the DPR also needs to ensure the existence of a supervisory mechanism for the criminal asset management institution so that the public can oversee the accountability and transparency of the institution’s performance,” said Wana.
The journey of the Asset Forfeiture Bill
The Asset Forfeiture Bill has undergone a long journey since its initial drafting was initiated by the Financial Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (PPATK) in 2008. The bill was even included as one of the promises in Joko Widodo-Jusuf Kalla’s Nawa Cita during the 2014 election contest. However, it was only in May 2023 that Jokowi issued a Presidential Letter along with the academic paper and official draft, and submitted it to the DPR as a government-initiated bill.
However, the 2019-2024 DPR never discussed it until its term ended in September 2024.
One year later, the DPR instead took over the bill as a DPR initiative, meaning the draft and academic paper that had been available since 2023 had to be redrafted from scratch.
For the coalition, the takeover did not accelerate the process but rather slowed it down while opening a gap to change the substance of the 2023 draft.
The government’s 2023 draft was also not perfect because it had undergone compromising changes compared to the initial draft that had been prepared by PPATK.
In August 2026, the Chairman of Commission III of the DPR, Habiburokhman, stated that the DPR wanted to complete the Asset Forfeiture Bill soon and ensured it would be passed no later than December 2026 at a Plenary Session.
The DPR claimed that the discussion of this regulation had gone through 35 public hearing meetings and three working visits.
Although the DPR has claimed to have held meetings to discuss the Asset Forfeiture Bill, the draft in question has never been opened to the public.
According to the coalition, the DPR’s move to discuss the Asset Forfeiture Bill from scratch is also questionable, given that the government had already prepared and submitted the complete academic paper and the Asset Forfeiture Bill to the DPR in October 2024.
“This step should be suspected as an effort to delay the discussion and passage, as well as to isolate the discussion from the public and the government itself as the parties that should be the DPR’s tandem in drafting and discussing the bill,” explained Wana.
“Thus, the Asset Forfeiture Bill being drafted by the DPR has the potential to eliminate crucial articles that target certain groups,” he continued.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/critical-notes-on-the-asset-forfeiture-bill-from-the-civil-society-coalition-1787809913)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260827115647-12-1396882/catatan-kritis-soal-ruu-perampasan-aset-dari-koalisi-masyarakat-sipil), translated from Indonesian