Criminal Law Expert: Suspect Designation Remains Valid Without Prior Witness Examination
Criminal law expert Henry Yosodiningrat has emphasised that the designation of an individual as a suspect remains legally valid even if the person concerned has not been examined as a witness. He stated that this applies if investigators have obtained at least two valid pieces of evidence.
The suspect designation of former Junior Attorney General for Special Crimes (Jampidsus) Febrie Adriansyah recently sparked controversy because he had not been examined as a witness. According to Henry, the legal basis refers to Law Number 20 of 2025 concerning the new Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP).
He explained that Article 90 of the new KUHAP clearly regulates the procedure for designating a suspect. However, the norm does not stipulate the examination of the prospective suspect as an absolute preliminary requirement.
‘The provisions in Law Number 20 of 2025 only require a minimum of two valid pieces of evidence as the basis for designating a suspect,’ Henry said in a written statement in Jakarta, Saturday (18/7).
He stressed the importance of the principles of legal certainty, namely lex scripta (written law) and lex stricta (strict law). According to him, law enforcement officials and judges are not permitted to add procedural requirements or conditions for annulling a suspect designation that are not explicitly stated in the law.
Regarding the reference to Constitutional Court Decision Number 21/PUU-XII/2014, which is often used to challenge the validity of a suspect designation without prior examination, Henry noted that the decision reviewed Law Number 8 of 1981, which has now been revoked and replaced by the new KUHAP (Law No. 20/2025). Therefore, the 2014 Constitutional Court ruling cannot be automatically applied to Article 1 point 28 and Article 90 of the new KUHAP. Henry added that the obligation to examine a prospective suspect was actually only contained in the court’s legal considerations, not in the ruling’s dictum.
Furthermore, he cited Constitutional Court Decision Number 150/PUU-XXIV/2026, which declared a petition to review the provisions of the new KUHAP inadmissible. To date, there has been no Constitutional Court ruling declaring the articles in the new KUHAP unconstitutional regarding the absence of an obligation to examine a prospective suspect.
Although it is not a constitutive requirement for the validity of a suspect designation, Henry stressed that the examination of a suspect remains crucial in the investigation process. The examination serves as a means of clarification and fulfils the suspect’s rights in the evidentiary process.
‘What is tested in a pretrial hearing is not merely whether the prospective suspect has been examined, but whether at the time of the designation there were at least two valid, relevant pieces of evidence that objectively point to the involvement of the person designated,’ he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/criminal-law-expert-suspect-designation-remains-valid-without-prior-witness-examination-1784389852)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/912251/penetapan-tersangka-sah-tanpa-didahului-pemeriksaan-sebagai-saksi), translated from Indonesian