Court Overturns KPPU Ruling on Online Lending Interest-Rate Cartel
The Commercial Court at the Central Jakarta District Court has overturned the Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) ruling on online lending interest rates.
The ruling had been imposed on 97 peer-to-peer (P2P) lending fintech companies suspected of participating in an online lending interest-rate cartel. The 97 companies subsequently challenged the KPPU decision.
The judgment was delivered in a public hearing on Thursday, 22 October 2026. The panel was chaired by Anton Rizal Setiawan, with Achmad Rasyid Purba and M Arief Adikusumo as members.
Central Jakarta District Court spokesperson Sunoto said that, following the annulment of the KPPU ruling, the court ordered the respondent to pay court costs of Rp23,592,000.
The judgment set out several considerations. First, it considered whether the ceiling had been established under Financial Services Authority (OJK) guidance. When the lending industry emerged and developed, there were no rules governing it, including clear provisions on supervision. The OJK therefore issued guidance, including setting an upper limit on interest rates. The court considered that ceiling part of the state action doctrine, introduced to fill a legal vacuum (rechtsvacuu).
“The upper interest-rate limit was guidance accompanied by the threat of sanctions against businesses that breached it, issued by the state authority responsible for supervision—in this case, the OJK. The OJK also actively supervised the policy, including through OJK Circular Letter No. 19/SEOJK.06/2023, which took effect on 1 January 2024,” Sunoto said in a written statement, quoted on Friday, 23 October 2026.
The court gave several other reasons for overturning the decision.
Price ceiling and price-fixing
The court said a price ceiling is not prohibited by law and is different from price-fixing. It considered the ceiling a measure that protects consumers from lenders setting excessive interest rates. Lenders remained free to set their own rates as long as they did not exceed the ceiling.
This was consistent with testimony before the Commission from witness Entjik Sjahrudin Djafar, chairman of the Indonesian Joint Funding Fintech Association (AFPI), and borrower Evisto Dion Ariya. They said that lenders charged different interest rates in practice despite the ceiling in the code of conduct. Borrower Dani Widodo also testified that rates could be negotiated and varied according to a borrower’s track record.
Relevant market
The judges disagreed with the respondent’s position that the interest-rate limits in AFPI’s 2018, 2020 and 2021 codes of conduct applied to all the respondents, whether they operated on conventional or sharia principles. The court said sharia principles do not recognise interest, as discussed in its reasoning, and that sharia businesses were overseen by Sharia Supervisory Boards. No objections to the operations of sharia-based businesses had been raised by those boards during the proceedings.
On that basis, the panel concluded that conventional and sharia markets involved services that were neither the same nor interchangeable, and therefore did not meet the requirements for being treated as one relevant market.
Agreement
The judges also found that the businesses had not reached an agreement. Rather, they had been compelled to comply with AFPI guidelines that not all the applicants had helped draft, under threat of sanctions for non-compliance.
The court therefore found no concerted action by the applicants to set a ceiling on interest rates. It also cited the testimony of AFPI chairman Entjik Sjahrudin Djafar and borrower Evisto Dion Ariya that lenders charged different rates despite the ceiling in the code of conduct, as well as Dani Widodo’s testimony that rates could be negotiated and changed according to borrowers’ track records.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/court-overturns-kppu-ruling-on-online-lending-interest-rate-cartel-1792734676)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20261023120231-17-778870/pengadilan-batalkan-putusan-kppu-soal-bunga-kartel-bunga-pinjol), translated from Indonesian