Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Countering the Trend of Single Candidates: Restoring Competition in Regional Elections

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Countering the Trend of Single Candidates: Restoring Competition in Regional Elections
Image: Media Indonesia

The phenomenon of single-candidate pairs in regional elections (Pilkada) continues to increase with every election cycle. This condition has raised concerns regarding the quality of democratic competition and has prompted calls for a thorough reform of the regional head nomination design.

In its latest research titled ‘Strengthening Pilkada Competition with the Concept of Maximum Coalition Threshold and Write-in Vote to Prevent Single Candidates’, the Muhammadiyah Central Leadership shows that the number of single-candidate pairs has steadily risen. From only three regions in the 2015 elections, the number grew to nine in 2017, 16 in 2018, 25 in 2020, and reached 37 regions in the 2024 elections. At the start of the 2024 registration period, there were even 43 regions with only one candidate pair.

The Vice Chairman of the Muhammadiyah Law and Human Rights Council (MHH), Rahmat Muhajir Nugroho, assessed that this trend indicates a pattern of political party support consolidation that has the potential to eliminate competition. Consequently, Muhammadiyah proposes the implementation of an upper threshold for political party support, capped at 50%, in regional head nominations.

“We do not prohibit parties from forming coalitions, but we must limit support to ensure at least two candidate pairs are created. Currently, there is only a lower threshold of 6.5%, but there is no upper threshold. Without an upper threshold, 100% support could occur again in the future,” Rahmat stated during a Focus Group Discussion (FGD) and Validation of the Draft Academic Paper for the Regional Election Law in Jakarta on Saturday (13/9).

According to him, the existence of a lower threshold alone is insufficient to ensure the availability of alternative candidates. Without an upper limit, all political parties can join forces to support a single pair, making it difficult for other candidates to secure the political vehicle necessary to register.

Rahmat even questioned the assumption that the increase in single candidates is merely a coincidence of political conditions. Based on Muhamende research, there is a tendency for political parties to monopolise support to ensure victory for a single candidate pair.

“Therefore, our suspicion that this is unintentional is highly doubtful. There is a visible pattern of attempting to win regional elections by monopolising all political parties to support one specific pair,” he said.

This phenomenon, Rahmat noted, has the potential to evolve into ‘cartel politics’, where political parties prefer to join a single dominant force rather than compete by offering ideas, programmes, and candidates to the public. Coalition dominance can also eliminate opposition and weaken the check-and-balance function in the regions.

“Ultimately, what is known as cartel politics occurs, where political competition ceases to exist. What was once a competition of ideology and programmes eventually transforms into political cooperation aimed solely at the interests of individual political parties,” he added.

Therefore, Muhammadiyah believes that the mechanism of a single candidate pair running against an empty box (blank column) cannot serve as a permanent solution. Rahmat acknowledged that the empty box can serve as a channel for public dissent, but the mechanism does not provide balanced competition between candidates.

“Does providing an empty box channel solve the problem? It turns out it does not, because if the empty box wins, a re-run of the regional election (PSU) must be held, which requires significant funds and leads to elite pressure and voter fatigue,” he explained.

Limiting Coalitions, Removing Thresholds

University of Indonesia Election Law expert Titi Anggraini urged a redesign of the regional head nomination process to prevent coalition dominance and expand voter choices. She proposed a maximum coalition limit of 40-50% of the total number of election participants, rather than basing it on previous election votes or seats.

“I propose between 40 to 50% of the total participating political parties, because votes and seats should not be relevant as they are based on past election results,” said Titi.

According to Titi, the minimum nomination threshold also needs to be abolished so that all participating political parties have the opportunity to nominate candidate pairs. This step is considered capable of increasing candidate diversity and preventing the concentration of support on a single pair.

“For me, to achieve political diversity, the struggle remains in the removal of the minimum nomination threshold. The minimum requirement of seats or votes to nominate a candidate should be abolished,” she asserted.

In addition to the party route, Titi encouraged strengthening independent candidates by lowering the support requirement to 3%, similar to the system in Aceh. The registration schedules for independent candidates and party-backed candidates should also be synchronised so that candidates who fail to secure party support still have the opportunity to run.

“I strongly advocate for independent nomination requirements to be equalised with the regulations in the Aceh Governance Law, Law Number 11 of 2006, which is 3%,” Titi stated.

Titi also requested that political parties be mandated to nominate candidate pairs. Parties that fail to nominate a candidate could face sanctions, such as being barred from participating in the next local legislative elections (DPRD). This scheme is expected to encourage parties to provide alternative candidates rather than simply joining a winning coalition. “Parties may join coalitions as long as it does not create dominance that restricts the number of candidate pairs and voter choices,” she said.

Furthermore, Titi noted that reforms must also address the internal workings of political parties. The centralisation of nominations at the central elite level is seen as narrowing the space for cadres and local communities to determine candidates. Therefore, she encouraged strengthening regeneration and the implementation of preliminary elections.

More from 17 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/countering-the-trend-of-single-candidates-restoring-competition-in-regional-elections-1789661320)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/pilkada/934675/menghadang-tren-calon-tunggal-memulihkan-kompetisi-pilkada), translated from Indonesian
Print