Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Controversy over Welfare Decile Determination in Yogyakarta Special Region

| Source: detikJogja Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Controversy over Welfare Decile Determination in Yogyakarta Special Region
Image: detikJogja

The Yogyakarta Special Region (DIY) administration has protested over data on community welfare groupings, or deciles, which have undergone many changes. The DIY regional government and the DIY Central Statistics Agency (BPS) held a meeting to align the data.

The meeting was held at the office of the DIY Regional Secretary, Kepatihan Complex, Yogyakarta City, on Thursday afternoon (20/8). It was attended by the DIY Regional Secretary and staff, as well as the Acting Head of BPS DIY and staff.

DIY Regional Secretary Ni Made Dwi Panti Indrayanti said the meeting discussed the determination of deciles, which falls under the authority of the central government. According to Made, the DIY regional government needs to understand the criteria and basis for the grouping so that the data used in poverty handling can be fully understood and aligned with conditions in the region.

“The data comes from the centre, not something we determine. What we discuss is the criteria and how far they go. We need to ask BPS how they compile and classify it,” Made said in a written statement received by detikJogja on Thursday evening (20/8/2026).

Made explained that the DIY regional government also has data developed through collaboration with district and city governments. The data is integrated into Satu Data Kemiskinan (One Poverty Data) and provides a detailed picture of community conditions.

“With that single data system, we can monitor the situation. It is already very detailed in terms of which poverty category people fall into, what assistance they receive, and what type it is. It is all visible there,” she said.

“We are not trying to compare data, but rather to align it,” she added.

Meanwhile, Acting Head of BPS DIY Endang Tri Wahyuningsih said the Data Tunggal Sosial dan Ekonomi Nasional (DTSEN) is a database that integrates social and economic information to support more targeted government policies.

She explained that DTSEN was built through the integration of various data sources such as Regsosek, DTKS, and P3KE, enriched with data from PLN, BPJS Kesehatan, and others. It is then matched with population administration data.

In DTSEN, family data is collected based on relative welfare levels, then ranked and divided into 10 groups called deciles. Decile 1 covers the 10 percent of families with the lowest relative welfare level, while Decile 10 represents the 10 percent of families with the highest relative welfare level.

“The determination of decile position takes into account 41 input variables grouped into family identity information, housing information (condition and quality of dwelling), asset ownership, and family member information (education, employment, income, disability, and chronic illness),” she explained.

“Therefore, deciles cannot be equated with income levels nor used as an absolute label stating that someone is rich or poor,” Endang continued.

Endang added that DTSEN is continuously updated and results are available every three months. As a result, a family’s socio-economic condition can change and its decile position can also shift following updates and data refreshes from various sources.

“The most important thing is how we work together to maintain data quality so that it can complement each other,” Endang said.

For residents who feel their economic condition does not match the decile position listed, they can carry out independent updates through the Cek Bansos application or the Cek DTSEN channel. However, a submission does not automatically change the decile because the data must first go through a verification and validation process.

According to the DIY Social Affairs Office (Dinsos), the frequent changes in poverty status data are inappropriate.

“I do not understand the dynamics either. We do not know why BPS changes the deciles almost every week. That is not proper for data,” said Head of the DIY Social Affairs Office Suyarno when contacted by detikJogja on Friday (21/8/2026).

For information, the welfare grouping data, or deciles, refers to the Data Tunggal Sosial Ekonomi Nasional (DTSEN). Through this system, Indonesian citizens are grouped into 10 categories or deciles.

Each decile covers about 10 percent of the population, with decile 1 as the group with the lowest welfare level and decile 10 as the group with the highest welfare level.

Decile determination does not only look at family income. A number of other indicators are also taken into account, ranging from housing conditions, education, employment of family members, electricity usage, to asset ownership.

Suyarno said the recent changes in community decile data were due to the many indicators used, which do not match the actual conditions of the community today.

“The authority to determine deciles lies with BPS at the central level. Regarding deciles, our perception is that when additional data enters DTSEN, for example BKKBN data, it may, in quotation marks, disrupt things,” Suyarno said.

“Because some people’s deciles have jumped up, with the reason being that the data source is BKKBN. Some may be matched, and that is what the BKKBN data is like. So it will later be matched with DTSEN data, ‘oh right, it turns out this matches the decile’, like that. Even though, in quotation marks, the decile change is extraordinary,” he added.

To resolve this issue, Suyarno said BPS and the regional government must immediately carry out data matching to obtain concrete data on the actual conditions of the community.

“Data matching must certainly be carried out. Because when someone is in decile 8 or decile 7, but the actual conditions on the ground should not be like that. Their house, their income, and so on turn out not to match. That is what may need attention,” he explained.

More from 22 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/controversy-over-welfare-decile-determination-in-yogyakarta-special-region-1787356236)
Originally published by detikJogja (https://www.detik.com/jogja/berita/d-8629362/polemik-penentuan-desil-kesejahteraan-masyarakat-di-diy), translated from Indonesian
Print