Controversy Over Philadelphia Slavery Memorial as Dark History Is Silenced
The Trump administration has carried out its plan to replace the panels at the President’s House site in Philadelphia, where George Washington lived in the 1790s when the city served as the capital of the United States.
The President’s House, which is part of the Independence National Historical Park, has until now featured panels and videos focusing on the lives of the nine people forced to work as slaves in the house, serving Washington and his wife, Martha.
Criticism: The new panels soften the history of slavery
The administration of Donald Trump sought to revise the exhibition under a 2025 executive order titled “Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History”. The order aims to remove content from historical and cultural institutions that, according to the government, “improperly defame Americans, both living and dead”.
The new version of the exhibition, installed on Wednesday (15/07), still retains references to those enslaved at the house, as well as information about the abolitionist movement.
However, critics argue that the new exhibition presents a softer picture of Washington’s views on slavery.
One example is a panel titled “The Dirty Business of Slavery”, which was removed and replaced with “Celebrating Independence Throughout the Years”.
The new panels also removed material from the previous exhibition, including a map of slave trade routes and a timeline tracing the history of slavery. Meanwhile, descriptions of Washington’s views and treatment of enslaved people were toned down.
Legal battle between the federal government and the city
The replacement of the panels, carried out before the site opened on Wednesday (15/07), marks the latest chapter in the dispute between the Trump administration and the City of Philadelphia.
After the President’s House site was selected for alteration, the original panels were removed in January. Some were reinstalled the following month after Philadelphia successfully sued in federal district court, arguing that the government was obliged to consult the city before making changes.
The exhibition was only partially restored for months while the legal case continued, even through Philadelphia’s Fourth of July Independence Day celebrations.
Philadelphia mayor condemns the removal of panels
Earlier this month, the Trump administration won its appeal, which then triggered the installation of the new panels on Wednesday (15/07).
Cherelle Parker, the Mayor of Philadelphia, promised to “keep fighting” in a post on X.
“Last night, under the cover of darkness, the federal government removed the panels at the President’s House that tell Philadelphia’s history in full,” she said.
“This was permitted by a federal court decision, but the fact that they did it at night shows they know this action is shameful and a betrayal of the community’s trust.”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/controversy-over-philadelphia-slavery-memorial-as-dark-history-is-silenced-1784289238)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/dw/d-8578715/kontroversi-memorial-perbudakan-philadelphia-saat-sejarah-kelam-dibungkam), translated from Indonesian