Constitutional Law Expert Says Vice Presidential Impeachment Issue Must Be Read Through Constitutional Mechanisms
The uproar over the position of Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia Gibran Rakabuming Raka has resurfaced in the public sphere. A number of issues relating to his candidacy process in the 2024 General Election have again been linked to the discourse of dismissing or impeaching the Vice President. Constitutional law expert and lecturer at the Faculty of Law of Pancasila University, Fritz Edward Siregar, through his social media account, assessed that the matter needs to be placed within the proper constitutional framework.
According to him, disputes regarding the nomination and the mechanism for dismissing the Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia are matters that have different legal pathways. Fritz also explained that the 1945 Constitution does not grant the President the authority to unilaterally dismiss the Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia.
“First, friends, referring to Article 8 of the 1945 Constitution, the President is not within the chain of authority to dismiss the Vice President. Both are elected together by the people, so the President has no constitutional authority to dismiss his deputy,” said Fritz, quoted from a press release received on Wednesday (12/8).
According to Fritz, the provisions regarding the dismissal of the President or Vice President have been specifically regulated in the constitution. Therefore, the emergence of accusations or debates regarding the nomination process cannot immediately be translated into the dismissal of the Vice President. He also highlighted the use of the phrase “no longer meets the requirements” in Article 7A of the 1945 Constitution, which has recently become a subject of debate again.
“In constitutional law, that article applies to conditions at the time of holding office, not a retroactive appeal mechanism to annul nomination disputes,” he said.
Fritz then reminded that the Constitutional Court had previously issued a ruling regarding issues that arose in the nomination process for the 2024 Presidential Election. According to him, Constitutional Court Decision Number 90 still has legal force after the Court again provided considerations in Constitutional Court Decision Number 141 of 2023.
“In the legal considerations at points 3.13.2 and 3.13.3, the Constitutional Court explicitly affirmed the principle of res judicata pro veritate habetur, that Decision 90 de jure remains valid, binding, and there is no other option for the Court but to comply with it,” explained Fritz.
He also touched on the ruling on the 2024 Presidential Election Results Dispute, which had examined various objections regarding the nomination process.
“Not only that, friends, all allegations of nomination violations have also been legally rejected in the ruling on the 2024 Presidential Election Results Dispute,” he said.
Therefore, Fritz reminded that the impeachment discourse should not be detached from the constitutional mechanism that was deliberately established to regulate the process of dismissing the President or Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia. According to him, the experience of the impeachment of President Abdurrahman Wahid is one of the important backgrounds for why the mechanism was subsequently laid out more clearly in the constitution.
“And for us, teachers of constitutional law, we have all learned together that the impeachment process is not something that is easy to carry out. We have past experience and we place it within constitutional spaces. That is why we need a mechanism,” he explained.
Thus, according to Fritz, debates regarding the nomination or documents that have resurfaced in the public sphere cannot automatically be equated with the impeachment process. Every issue must still be placed within its respective legal and constitutional mechanism.
“But that mechanism is what we want to build together. Not merely repeating issues that have already been concluded,” Fritz concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-law-expert-says-vice-presidential-impeachment-issue-must-be-read-through-constitutional-1786528254)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/920977/pakar-hukum-tata-negara-sebut-isu-pemakzulan-wapres-harus-dibaca-melalui-mekanisme-konstitusi), translated from Indonesian