Constitutional Law Expert: MPR Speaker's Appointment as Iran Envoy is President's Prerogative
Fahri Bachmid, a constitutional law expert from the Indonesian Muslim University, has given his view on the appointment of the Speaker of the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR RI), Ahmad Muzani, as President Prabowo Subianto’s special envoy to attend the funeral of Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. The appointment of Muzani as the President’s special envoy had drawn public criticism, particularly given his position as MPR Speaker.
According to Fahri, the President’s decision to task Ahmad Muzani alongside Foreign Minister Sugiono is a consequence of the President’s constitutional standing as the highest diplomatic head of the nation. Under the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, a Head of State is recognised as the principal representative of a country, holding full authority over foreign relations.
“Technically speaking, Ahmad Muzani’s position in this mission is not as an institutional representative of the MPR, which is functionally equal to the President within the constitutional structure. The President is exercising his prerogative as Head of State, who holds the constitutional authority to appoint anyone he deems fit to represent the state and the Indonesian nation in an activity or diplomatic mission abroad,” Fahri said in a written statement on Wednesday (8 July).
Fahri explained that in the President’s ceremonial role as a symbol of political sovereignty, unity and the official representation of the state, a President is not directly involved in day-to-day technical policymaking. However, he leads the nation’s representation at the international level, which grants full legitimacy to appoint particular figures as Presidential Special Envoys, outside the ranks of cabinet ministers or the regular diplomatic corps.
Therefore, the mandate abroad to Mashhad, Iran, was carried out purely in a personal capacity as Special Envoy, not as MPR Speaker, and was coordinated directly with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs as the agency directing international diplomacy.
Fahri noted that although, constitutionally, the position of the presidency is equal to the leadership of high state institutions such as the MPR, the assignment remains legally valid. This rests on the President’s discretion as the holder of the mandate of governmental power and head of the state’s diplomacy to set the direction of politics on the international stage, as regulated under Article 6 paragraph (1) of Law No. 37 of 1999 on Foreign Relations.
From the perspective of national positive law instruments, the position is specifically supported by technical regulations on the appointment of special executive officials. “The position and authority of a Presidential Special Envoy are specifically regulated in Presidential Regulation No. 106 of 2025 on Special Advisors, Special Envoys, Special Staff and Special Assistants to the President, and Special Staff to the Vice President, as set out in Chapter II, Articles 16, 17 and 18. These provisions stipulate that, to facilitate the President’s duties, a Special Envoy is appointed to carry out specific tasks outside the scope of the organisation and portfolio of ministries or other government agencies,” he explained.
Fahri added that the regulation permits the President to choose figures from among professionals, public figures or politicians, provided the individual is deemed to possess the required competence. Nevertheless, the regulation contains clear limits on authority, stipulating that a special envoy has no executive authority to make legally binding decisions or policies in the manner of a minister, and is prohibited from taking over the core duties of a ministry.
“Thus, the President holds the constitutional authority to appoint a Presidential Special Envoy under the provisions of Presidential Regulation No. 106 of 2025, which grants the President full authority to appoint officials who carry out specific tasks outside the portfolio of particular ministries or agencies,” Fahri concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-law-expert-mpr-speakers-appointment-as-iran-envoy-is-presidents-prerogative-1783518672)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/908908/pakar-hukum-tata-negara-nilai-penunjukan-ketua-mpr-ke-iran-hak-prerogatif-presiden), translated from Indonesian