Constitutional Law Expert: Gibran Should Automatically Lose Vice-Presidential Position
Herdiansyah Hamzah, a constitutional law expert at Mulawarman University, said Indonesian Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s position had constitutionally lapsed following rulings by the Constitutional Court (MK) and the Supreme Court (MA).
“The finding that [the document] was invalid, with the consequence that he did not meet the requirements to be a vice-presidential candidate at the time, means that Gibran’s position as vice-president should in fact automatically lapse,” Herdiansyah said on Sunday (1 November).
Herdiansyah first discussed the eligibility requirements for vice-presidential candidates. He said the Supreme Court ruling upheld the Constitutional Court’s decision that Gibran did not meet the requirements to stand as a vice-presidential candidate.
“If we look at the Supreme Court ruling, which in fact also upheld the Constitutional Court’s decision, Gibran essentially did not meet the requirements to become a vice-presidential candidate,” he said.
The decisions refer to the outcome of a Constitutional Court hearing on Tuesday (6 October). The court said it had found no convincing evidence that Gibran held a foreign diploma, certificate or degree that could be recognised as equivalent to having completed at least senior high school, an Islamic senior high school (MA), a vocational senior high school (SMK), a vocational Islamic senior high school, or an equivalent school, as required under Articles 169(r) and 227(l) of the General Elections Law.
On Friday (30 October), the Supreme Court also ruled that the certificate equating Gibran’s education with senior high school, which he used to meet the registration requirements for the 2024 presidential election, was invalid.
“Something that is invalid can be considered never to have existed, or as having reverted to its original state. That means the certificate equating his qualification was treated as if it had never existed in Gibran’s candidacy process,” Herdiansyah said.
In light of the rulings, Herdiansyah argued that Gibran’s current status as vice-president had also automatically lapsed.
“If we refer to Article 7A of the Constitution, the vice-president in this case can be classified as no longer meeting the requirements to serve as vice-president,” he said.
Article 7A of the Constitution concerns the removal of the president or vice-president in certain circumstances, including when they are proven to have committed a legal violation or no longer meet the requirements for office.
Questions had also arisen over how the rulings might affect the Prabowo-Gibran ticket. Herdiansyah stressed that the decisions had implications only for Gibran’s possible impeachment, not for Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto.
“In the context of the Constitutional Court ruling, subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court, what is at issue is the certificate equating his educational qualification, which Gibran used as the basis for registering in the 2024 election,” Herdiansyah said.
“So, from the perspective of constitutional law and Article 7A, it is Gibran who would be impeached,” he added.
Gibran’s lawyer rejects claim
Separately, Gibran’s lawyer, Muhammad Rullyandi, said the Supreme Court ruling did not affect his client’s position as vice-president.
He argued that the ruling could not be fully implemented because the legal circumstances had changed before it was issued.
“I believe the Supreme Court ruling granting the application to invalidate Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s certificate equating his education with senior high school, which was an administrative requirement for his nomination as vice-president in the 2024 election, does not affect Gibran’s position as vice-president,” Rullyandi said, as quoted by detikcom on Saturday (31 October).
“The reason is that the Supreme Court ruling cannot be fully executed because a prior legal situation has arisen,” he added.
Rullyandi said the Supreme Court issued its ruling after all stages of the 2024 presidential election had concluded and Gibran had been formally inaugurated as vice-president. He therefore argued that it could not be applied retroactively.
“The ruling falls within the framework of Administrative Court proceedings, with reference to Article 117(1) of Law No. 5/1986, which essentially provides that a ruling that cannot be fully implemented cannot be executed because a prior legal situation has arisen,” he said.
Rullyandi also said the certificate had been used to meet the administrative requirements for nomination during the 2024 election process, which had since concluded. He maintained that although the Supreme Court ruling was final and binding, it could not be applied in this case.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-law-expert-gibran-should-automatically-lose-vice-presidential-position-1793595199)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261102092208-12-1422177/pakar-htn-posisi-gibran-sebagai-wapres-seharusnya-gugur), translated from Indonesian