Constitutional Justice Questions Government Oversight on Flight Delay Compensation
Constitutional Court (MK) judge Saldi Isra has questioned the effectiveness of government oversight of airlines regarding air transport services. He made the remarks during a judicial review hearing of Law Number 1 of 2009 on Aviation held on Tuesday (4/8).
Saldi highlighted the role of the Ministry of Transport in controlling various air service problems, ranging from departure delays to the transfer of flights to other airlines within the same corporate group.
In his view, the compensation currently applied is not commensurate with the actual losses experienced by passengers.
“To the government, what control have you exercised over problems like these? Matters like these cannot be measured merely in Rp300,000, sir,” Saldi asserted in response to the testimony of the government’s legal counsel and the party concerned, Lion Group.
During the hearing, the compensation mechanism currently in force for consumers based on the length of the delay was revealed. Saldi judged the amounts to fall far short of the potential losses incurred by passengers, particularly those with important commitments.
Saldi gave examples of uncompensated immaterial losses, such as passengers who missed attending a seminar, speaking as a presenter, or holding an important business meeting due to the delay.
“It becomes unreasonable if compensation is only Rp300,000 or merely replaced with light refreshments. The losses and potential losses are far greater,” he added.
Furthermore, Saldi asked the government to explain whether consumer protection agencies or aviation consumer associations had been involved in determining the compensation amounts.
He warned that airlines should not hide behind ministerial regulations as an excuse for implementing the law, while the value of consumers’ losses is ignored.
Saldi signalled that the Court may well issue a ruling requiring the involvement of consumer representatives in every adjustment of loss calculations, similar to the Court’s ruling concerning expired internet quotas some time ago.
“The government should not be favourable only to the airline companies; consumers must also be protected,” Saldi stressed.
Case number 190/PUU-XXIV/2026 was filed by nine advocates and two students. The petitioners are challenging the constitutionality of Article 146, the Elucidation of Article 146, Article 170, and Article 176 of the Aviation Law.
The petitioners argue that the current rules create legal uncertainty and an unbalanced position. They highlight a loophole that exempts airlines from liability without any obligation to provide valid proof of the delay, such as an official statement from the relevant authority.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/constitutional-justice-questions-government-oversight-on-flight-delay-compensation-1785891032)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/918421/hakim-mk-pertanyakan-pengawasan-pemerintah-soal-ganti-rugi-delay-pesawat), translated from Indonesian